Mormons for Racial Profiling? Unsustainable Contradictions in Immigration Law

What’s up with the Mormons? Orem, Utah legislator Stephen Eric Sandstrom last week pledged to follow the lead of “my friend” Arizona State Senator Russell Pearce and expand the number of states with show-me-your-papers bills aiming to criminalize, jail, and deport irregular migrants.

Rep. Sandstrom, who is a graduate of Brigham Young University and a former Mormon missionary to Venezuela, takes credit for co-founding a state’s rights organization called the Patrick Henry Caucus.

Sandstrom’s “friend”, Sen. Pearce of Arizona, sponsor of the recently signed SB-1070, hails from the Mormon stronghold of Mesa and claims to be the mastermind behind Maricopa County’s infamous Tent City Jail.

For Pearce and Sandstrom, the crucial issue of liberty in the 21st Century would appear to involve the rights of states in relation to the federal government of the USA — never mind the rights of individual people who reside in those states.

What’s curious about this particular Pearce-Sandstrom movement for state’s rights over individual rights is how it seems to contradict the interests of the Mormon family itself, which has been witnessing an increase in Spanish-speaking congregations.

Last summer, Salt Lake Tribune writer Peggy Fletcher Stack reported increasing fears among Spanish-speaking members of the Mormon Church of Latter-day Saints (LDS) who were concerned about travel restrictions they were facing for missionary work and then-impending implementation of Utah’s anti-migrant law, SB-81. “People are very scared,” said one woman via translator.

“Other than for its missionaries, the LDS Church takes a ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ approach toward the immigration status of its members,” reported Fletcher Stack. “But some estimate between 50 percent and 75 percent of members in Utah’s 104 Spanish-speaking congregations are undocumented. That includes many bishops, branch presidents, even stake presidents.”

Salt Lake City Police Chief Chris Burbank declared that Utah’s SB-81 would require illegal racial profiling, so he openly refused to enforce the self-contradictory statute. Last week Chief Burbank “blasted” Arizona’s SB-1070, telling KSL NewsRadio talk-show host Doug Wright: “This sets law enforcement back 30 to 40 years.”

Mormon Times columnist Jerry Earl Johnston shook his head last year in dismay over the unwisdom of the Utah anti-migrant legislation:

“I can only speak from my own LDS experience here, but I hold Utah lawmakers responsible for breaking up good LDS families and forcing young American citizens out of their native land,” wrote Johnston, predicting that victory would not reward the shortsighted anti-migrant forces.

I could see these Hispanic brethren were going to win,” wrote Johnston. “I could see their faith, resilience and strength. They wanted to be in Utah more than Utah lawmakers wanted them out. They had weathered tribulations with good humor and without malice toward those who persecuted them.”

Meanwhile, in the Mormon stronghold of Mesa, Arizona, represented by SB-1070 sponsor Sen. Pearce, the number of Spanish-speaking LDS congregations had grown from five to 13 between 2002 and 2007 according to East Valley Tribune reporter Sarah N. Lynch.

Last fall, official LDS printing presses in Salt Lake City ran off an approved Spanish-language edition of the Mormon Bible — The Santa Biblia: Reina-Valera 2009 (Publicada por La Iglesia de Jesucristo de los Santos de los Últimos Días Salt Lake City, Utah, E.U.A.) — with an initial press run of 800,000 copies.

It is one of the most significant scripture projects ever undertaken by the Church,” proclaimed a notice of Sept. 14, 2009 posted at “The volume contains new chapter headings, footnotes and cross-references to all scriptures used by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.” Announcement of the volume was reportedly shared among “thousands of Spanish-speaking Latter-day Saints congregations.”

Mormon political leaders, like everyone else in today’s global economy, are confronting a real crisis in human welfare. Maricopa County in particular is a frontline disaster zone for the crisis in real estate values, mortgage defaults, unemployment, and revenue shortfalls.

“In Maricopa,” according to an April report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics on Q3 2009 unemployment, “every private industry group except education and health services experienced an employment decline, with construction experiencing the largest decline (-32.2 percent).”

Crisis reveals character. So when Mormon political leaders campaign for agendas of states’ rights according to Patrick Henry rhetorics of “liberty or death,” perhaps their Spanish-speaking LDS brethren can remind them that there are millions of people of goodwill in need of actual freedom-loving legislators in whatever state they have freely chosen to congregate and build up.

Greg Moses is editor of the Texas Civil Rights Review and a member of the Texas Civil Rights Collective.. Read other articles by Greg, or visit Greg's website.

5 comments on this article so far ...

Comments RSS feed

  1. JE said on April 26th, 2010 at 8:45pm #

    What is a irregular migrant?

    A migrant with constipation?

    Serious the LDS should be prosecuted for contributing to the illegal immigration problem. Obvious they’re no better than the business community that takes advantage of these people.

  2. hayate said on April 28th, 2010 at 6:37pm #

    Is somebody at this site a Mormon? My post yesterday about Mormon criminals and terrorism got flagged and put on “moderation”, and was never posted.

    Let’s see how sensitive the moderator is about exposure of Mormon institutionalised racism. This racist arizona law is nothing new for Mormons. They refused to allow black people membership in to their church till 1978, and there are still very few black Mormons. The racism of the Mormon church has been heavily documented and is in fact part of the teachings within the Book of Mormon. For example, see this article:

    The embarrassing truth
    about Mormonism

    by Mark Wignall
    Sunday, September 25, 2005

  3. hayate said on April 28th, 2010 at 6:40pm #

    Mexico issues travel alert over new Arizona law

    By MARTHA MENDOZA, Associated Press Writer Martha Mendoza, 27 April, 2010

    MEXICO CITY – The Mexican government warned its citizens Tuesday to use extreme caution if visiting Arizona because of a tough new law that requires all immigrants and visitors to carry U.S.-issued documents or risk arrest.

    Two top U.S. officials, meanwhile, criticized the measure and said it may face a legal challenge by federal authorities.

    A Mexican government-affiliated agency that supports Mexicans living and working in the United States called for boycotts of Tempe, Ariz.-based US Airways, the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Phoenix Suns until those organizations rebuke the law.

    “We are making a strong call to the Arizona government to retract this regressive and racist law that’s impacting not only residents of Arizona, but people in all 50 states and in Mexico as well,” said Raul Murillo, who works with the Institute for Mexicans Abroad, an autonomous agency of Mexico’s Foreign Ministry…..

  4. hayate said on April 28th, 2010 at 6:42pm #

    Let’s try the post about Mormon criminality, war crimes and terrorism again:

    Something not well known about the drug running, torture and death squad training Iran-contra war criminals, oliver north and richard secord, and much of the rest of that war crime syndicate, is they were Mormons, and gave some of that drug money to the Mormon church and promoted Mormon missionaries in Latin America. North probably still does.

    Back in the 19th century, the u.s. had an opportunity to eradicate this racist cult once and for all after brigham young and the Mormon leadership had over a hundred people massacred. But they chickened out in the end.

    A description of the Mountain Meadows Massacre and the continued Mormon efforts to escape blame:

    September Dawn, A Movie About The Mormon’s “Mountain Meadows Massacre”, Set For Release On May 4, 2007

    See also:

  5. hayate said on April 28th, 2010 at 6:45pm #

    “Your comment is awaiting moderation – we’ll get to it ASAP!”

    Apparently, Mormon connections to Iran-contra or M.M. Massacre are taboo subjects at this site.