US Elections 2010: Learning from Defeat

In the US mid-term elections, Republicans picked up approximately 65 seats in the House for a 237-198 majority, and six seats in the Senate — including the Illinois seat formerly held by President Obama and that of liberal icon Russell Feingold of Wisconsin — for a 49-49 tie in the Senate, where two independents will hold the Democrats ransom. Republican leader John Boehner of Ohio will succeed Democrat Nancy Pelosi of California as speaker of the House. Republicans gained eight governorships, but Democrats hold the two biggest states: Andrew Cuomo beat Republican Carl Paladino in New York, and Jerry Brown returned to the governor’s job in California, defeating former eBay Chief Executive Meg Whitman.

This was a clear repudiation of Obama’s Bush-lite presidency. By failing to find a way to undo Bush’s policies, and introducing a health care policy that mostly benefits corporate insurance providers, the enthusiasm Obama gave rise to, gave way to an extreme right wing Tea Party movement reaction which has elected more Bush-like politicians than ever.

The only Democratic ray of hope was Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid of Nevada whose Tea Party opponent advocated ending Medicare and Social Security, abolishing the Energy and Education departments, and vastly reducing the size of government, turning even Republicans against her.

But the real problem is more Congress than Obama and will continue to fester. Seventy-three per cent disapproved of Congress and only 49 per cent of the job Obama is doing as president. An almost identical 72 per cent disapproved of Congress in 2008 while an unprecedented 73 per cent disapproved of Bush in his final year.

Obama has nothing to lose now by sticking to his principles. He can still rally Americans by pushing ahead with arms control and climate change measures, carrying through on his vow to end the war in Afghanistan next year, pressuring Israel to abide by international norms, thereby showing the Washington beltway cabal for what it is.

Eric Walberg is a journalist who worked in Uzbekistan and is now writing for Al-Ahram Weekly in Cairo. He is the author of From Postmodernism to Postsecularism and Postmodern Imperialism. His most recent book is Islamic Resistance to Imperialism. Read other articles by Eric, or visit Eric's website.

27 comments on this article so far ...

Comments RSS feed

  1. Josie Michel-Bruening said on November 4th, 2010 at 8:33am #

    I would like to join Eric Walberg’s view, according to the old song, “Freedom is just another word for nothing left to lose …”. My lightweight recommend to President Obama would be: Use your constitutional power as president of the United States whenever and as long as you can. There are some issues you are allowed to decide by your own. Despite of the bad heritage you faced by taking office in the White House, and as it turned out concerning domestic problems you seem to have too little support, but you seem to have some space concerning foreign affairs, as commander-in chief you need not agree to demands of the Pentagon and you have the right to pardon political prisoners, as for instance, Leonard Peltier, more than 30 years in prison, as for the “Cuban Five” more than 12 years in prison.
    You cannot lift the “embargo” against Cuba without the agreement of Congress, but being unpopular anyway among those who are insisting on it – while according polls 70 per cent of all Americans are advocating to lift the embargo – you can let the “Cuban Five” go home by an ink stroke.
    By this little gesture you could show the world that you don’t want to continue with the double standard of the so-called war against terror.

  2. 3bancan said on November 4th, 2010 at 8:48am #

    Eric Walberg continues to paint Obama in rosy colours, imho in accord with the taste of the moderator who deleted my previous comment…

  3. Don Hawkins said on November 4th, 2010 at 8:54am #

    The president said they can talk about moving forward, “In a way that, first of all, does no harm, that extends those tax cuts that are very important for middle-class families; also extends those provisions that are important to encourage businesses to invest and provide businesses some certainty over the next year or two.”

    The president said it is too early to say how the negotiations will work out, but that it is his hope that people are not gong to play “brinkmanship” but act responsibly.

    Is he willing to negotiate?

    “Absolutely” the president answered in one word to ABC’s Jake Tapper. ABC

    Well thank God no brinkmanship and there going to act responsibly. You see what an election can do as we all move closer to the center a force so strong not even light can escape.

  4. MichaelKenny said on November 4th, 2010 at 10:29am #

    A commentator in the London Independent thinks all this is not such bad news for Obama and I’m inclined to agree with him. Essentially, Obama was blocked by the Israel Lobby but no American politician dares to say that openly and he couldn’t really blame his own party. Now, he can blame the Republicans for everything. Equally, the Republican party is now deeply split. The Tea Party didn’t really win but it didn’t really lose either. It hasn’t hijacked the Republican party but it has enough “clout” to impose candidates here and there, but some of those candidates are totally unelectable. Thus, either the bluenose party boses get control of the Tea Party rednecks or the Tea Party might field its own candidate in 2012, which, given the electoral system, could well throw the election to Obama.
    Looked at from a foreign, more specifically European, perspective, Obama is indeed becoming the American Gorbachev. The American political system is gridlocked. The people want change. The Lobby has enough clout to block all change. Thus, the future seems to be a Soviet-style implosion rather than a soft landing. That’s good news for everybody, most of all perhaps, Americans. The one way to break the Lobby’s power is to make the US useless to it by destroying the American superpower. By gridlocking the system, the Lobby itself has made that inevitable.

  5. shabnam said on November 4th, 2010 at 10:56am #

    3bancan:

    Eric Walberg used to paint Russia that is in bed with Israel and the US as ‘victim’ of US imperialsim to mislead the public not to know that Russia cooperate with Israel and US to kill Muslims. Russia, has sold Iran to her enemy, Ahmadinejad said it yesterday. Russia should be treated like US imperalism and zionism, using Arabs and Muslims to enrich herself. Medvedev is controled by the zionists. Russia sells her arms that are obsolete to Syria and then signs military agreement with Aparthied state. Iranian people accused Russia as one possible source responsible for the introduction of visurs into computers at Bushehr reactor.
    Russian army chief of staff Gen. N. Makarov broke the news on September 22 that Russia will not sell the S-300 air defense systems to Iran. Regardless of official explanations, it does not take an expert to realize that as a purely defensive system designed to shield a country from aircraft and cruise missile attacks the S-300 complexes cannot pose a threat to any country unless it attacks the one owning them. What could be the motivation behind Russia’s recent decision? He asked.
    “Moscow has for years been playing the game of taming Iran’s alleged nuclear ambitions and voted for sanctions against the country in the UN Security Council.” He said
    http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=21157

    Don’t believe Russian propaganda by their agents who are trying to paint Russia as ‘victim’.

  6. Hue Longer said on November 4th, 2010 at 10:57am #

    Eric,

    It’s propaganda telling us that Obama or any Dem is “scared”. They are doing exactly what they they were put there to do

  7. shabnam said on November 4th, 2010 at 11:00am #

    3bancan:

    Eric Walberg used to paint Russia that is in bed with Israel and the US as ‘victim’ of US imperialsim to mislead the public not to know that Russia cooperate with Israel and US to kill Muslims. Russia, has sold Iran to her enemy, Ahmadinejad said it yesterday. Russia should be treated like US imperalism and zionism, using Arabs and Muslims to enrich herself. Medvedev is controled by the zionists. Russia sells her arms that are obsolete to Syria and then signs military agreement with Aparthied state. Iranian people accused Russia as one possible source responsible for the introduction of visurs into computers at Bushehr reactor.
    Russian army chief of staff Gen. N. Makarov broke the news on September 22 that Russia will not sell the S-300 air defense systems to Iran. Regardless of official explanations, it does not take an expert to realize that as a purely defensive system designed to shield a country from aircraft and cruise missile attacks the S-300 complexes cannot pose a threat to any country unless it attacks the one owning them. What could be the motivation behind Russia’s recent decision? He asked.
    “Moscow has for years been playing the game of taming Iran’s alleged nuclear ambitions and voted for sanctions against the country in the UN Security Council.” He said
    Don’t believe Russian propaganda by their agents who are trying to paint Russia as ‘victim’.

  8. Mulga Mumblebrain said on November 4th, 2010 at 11:57am #

    “There are none so blind as they who will not see”. I mean how many more betrayals will be needed before eyes are opened to the reality of Obama ‘The first Jewish President of the USA’ as Abner Mikvner chortled. Obama was groomed from college by Zionists, promoted, employed and then financed in politics by Zionists. His first appointment was Rahm Emanuel, who was followed by a raft of other Zionists and Goldman-Sachs pathocrats. He refused to prosecute torturers as international law demands. He refuses to close Guantanamo. He kills more women and children with drones than Bush. He threatens China. He lets Netanyahu cross the street to piss on him, even though he is not, yet, on fire. He sabotaged Copenhagen, as part of a Western conspiracy to foist the costs of climate change on the poor world. Etc, etc-I’m beginning to bore myself.
    Yet the poor ‘Hope Fiends’ still believe in this faery story of the Powerless Prince, dedicated to good, who just cannot get his way, no matter how charmingly he pouts or poses. My prediction is that Obama will play ‘lame duck’ with real pathos and flair, the Repugnicans will run amok, and in 2012 even more of the Hope Fiends will stay home, disillusioned, as planned, and the Mad Hatters, who will just grow more insane as the economy implodes and the Chinese refuse to obey orders like good little ‘Chinks’ or (if you prefer) ‘ChiComms’ and the ‘rag-heads’ keep on resisting their betters, will march to Glory. Then we’ll really be living in interesting times.

  9. Don Hawkins said on November 4th, 2010 at 12:09pm #

    “After there is great trouble among mankind, a greater one is prepared. The great mover of the universe will renew time, rain, blood, thirst, famine, steel weapons and disease. In the heavens, a fire seen.” Nostradamus

  10. mary said on November 4th, 2010 at 12:51pm #

    Nostrodamus was prescient when it comes to Haiti – rain, famime and disease.

    The poor people living in their cardboard and tin shelters amongst the rubble of the earthquake, now face the coming of Tropical Storm Tomas which will bring 15″ of rain with fears of mudslides and the spread of the cholera epidemic. What happened to the initiative of the war criminals George Bush and Bill Clinton to assist Haiti after the earthquake? Nothing has changed for them and they have nowhere to run to.

    http://www.channel4.com/news/cholera-hit-haiti-braced-for-tropical-storm-tomas

  11. Don Hawkins said on November 4th, 2010 at 2:49pm #

    Carlos Barrios, from the Eagle Clan of the Mam Maya of Guatemala shares in regards to 2012:

    “The world will not end. It will be transformed… Everything will change…Change is accelerating now, and it will continue to accelerate…If the people of the earth can get to this 2012 date in good shape, without having destroyed too much of the Earth, we will rise to a new, higher level. But to get there we must transform enormously powerful forces that seek to block the way…Humanity will continue, but in a different way. Material structures will change. From this we will have the opportunity to be more human…”

  12. Don Hawkins said on November 4th, 2010 at 3:06pm #

    “But to get there we must transform enormously powerful forces that seek to block the way…”

    And what are the tool’s of the trade the few use to block the way…

  13. Don Hawkins said on November 4th, 2010 at 3:20pm #

    In Oz did the Wizard know how it worked or through the use of smoke and mirror’s, illusion fool many.

  14. diane said on November 4th, 2010 at 5:00pm #

    I think your all being a bit pessimistic, after all, it has only taken 2 years for the american people to see Barrack Obama in his true col0urs. While many may have voted for reactionary politics, it appears many did not vote at all, thus the support Obama garnered from those wanting change has clearly dissipitated and this can only be a good thing, no.
    A negative outcome would have been for the young, the black the hispanic groups to have continued to follow Obama, I would have felt really depressed if that had happened. Although I am not an american, I overall feel positive about the american people in a way i have not done for many years.

  15. teafoe2 said on November 4th, 2010 at 5:14pm #

    just a note of encouragement to Mulga and Mary.

  16. Rehmat said on November 4th, 2010 at 6:08pm #

    No matter which of the two parties gain majority – The winner is always the same.

    On November 3, 2010 – Israel daily Haaretz reported:

    America’s largest pro-Israel lobby group on Wednesday hailed the results of midterm elections in the US which saw staunch supporters re-elected to Congress on both sides of the party political divide.

    “Many of the strongest friends and supporters of the U.S.-Israel relationship were reelected on Tuesday,” the group said in a statement.

    “It is abundantly clear that the 112th Congress will continue America’s long tradition of staunch support for a strong, safe and secure Israel and an abiding friendship between the United States and our most reliable ally in the Middle East,” AIPAC said.

    “Support for Israel at the Congress is strong and bipartisan,” an embassy spokesman told Haaretz.

    AIPAC also welcomed the election of three new Jewish members of Congress: Senator-elect Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), Congressman-elect David Cicilline (D-RI), and Congresswoman-elect Nan Hayworth (R-NY).

    Cicilline becomes the fourth openly gay member of Congress and third Jewish gay member of Congress……

    http://rehmat2.wordpress.com/2010/11/04/us-election-results-bode-more-evil-for-iran/

  17. Hue Longer said on November 4th, 2010 at 6:53pm #

    diane, that was awesome

  18. hayate said on November 4th, 2010 at 8:07pm #

    Mulga Mumblebrain said on November 4th, 2010 at 11:57am

    Great comment.

    mary said on November 4th, 2010 at 12:51pm

    Thanks for the info.

    Eric Walberg

    “Obama has nothing to lose now by sticking to his principles.”

    That’s what he has been doing all along. Sticking to HIS principles. I don’t understand how intelligent people can fail to understand that. There is absolutely nothing substantial in the man’s past record that shows he is anything other than a “friendly fascist” (to use the term invented by Bertram Gross to describe modern america and the political policies they pursue). Obama has been “the tel avivian candidate” from day one of his political career.

  19. shabnam said on November 4th, 2010 at 8:50pm #

    Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov announced again today that his government intends to do more to help with NATO’s struggling occupation of Afghanistan, though following his talks with NATO chief Anders Fogh Rasmussen the Russian FM stopped short of offering any specifics.

    There is no difference between Russia and US imperialism and zionism. All are invovled in killing, occupation and spying on Muslims.

    http://news.antiwar.com/2010/11/03/russia-vows-help-in-afghan-war/

    Expose those agents who paint Russia differently.

  20. Don Hawkins said on November 5th, 2010 at 12:34am #

    Things are certainly moving right ahead here in the greatest nation on Earth. Marco Rubio a quote and the election in Florida that I might add will be under water somewhat in a blink of an eye. Tthe US as “simply the greatest nation in all of human history.” A very bold thing to say indeed. Then yesterday John Boehner is that how you spell his last name is going to bring health care in the greatest nation in all of human history back to the people who live here I guess. Repeal and replace is that one of those tool’s of the trade and then old Mitch McConnell is he an enormously powerful force that seek’s to block the way…..as he said the people have spoken and said no to Obama and yes to us. Oh boy these enormously powerful force that seek’s to block the way in simply the greatest nation in all of human history are in battle or is that just an illusion. I wonder if they ever read this; if the people of the earth can get to this 2012 date in good shape, without having destroyed too much of the Earth we will have the opportunity to be more human…The American people have spoken and how much did that cost and not only in terms of money but our minds comes to mind. Boring this will not be although so far these tool’s of the trade the few use to block the way are almost right out of the pages of a fairytale.

  21. mary said on November 5th, 2010 at 12:46am #

    Thanks teafoe and hayate. Famime should be famine! And the last sentence reads as if Bush and Clinton have nowhere to run to. I meant that it was the people of Haiti who were trapped in such a dangerous and squalid situation. Meanwhile Bush and Clinton are living out their retirements in the height of luxury. I notice that both appeared pre-election, Bush Senior and the execrable son in a buggy. Still playing the fool. http://www.daylife.com/photo/09vtcgKfKu6R9?q=George+W.+Bush

    PS Bliss here today. The state broadcaster ZBC have their progammes disrupted by a 48 hour strike by the National Union of Jounalists. It was so nice to awake to a recorded nature programme instead of the usual propaganda. On Wednesday, there was a strike on the London Underground which brought London to a state of gridlock. This was NOT reported by ZBC or the MSM.

  22. Rehmat said on November 5th, 2010 at 5:13am #

    YES Shabnam – there is no difference between the US, Russia, Israel, France or even China when it comes to Muslims. They’re all colonial regimes run by anti-Muslim Zionists and they all still have Muslim lands under their occupation.

    Iran and the Russian ‘double standards’
    http://rehmat1.wordpress.com/2010/08/20/iran-and-the-russian-double-standards/

  23. Kim Petersen said on November 5th, 2010 at 7:06am #

    China is run by Zionists!? Really Rehmat? And China occupies Muslim land? This is silly. That there are Muslims in Xinjiang and elsewhere in China does not make the land occupied. There is no clear majority calling for separation from China. Half the Muslims in China are ethnic Chinese and are considered loyal to the country.
    China does have human rights abuses, and it does clamp down hard on unrest, but many Islamic countries do a much harsher job of oppressing Muslims than China.
    Moreover, China needs to protect the frontier. The country is encircled by US military bases. This does not legitimate human rights abuses in the least, but it is a sound argument for maintaining territorial integrity.

  24. 3bancan said on November 5th, 2010 at 8:00am #

    shabnam said on November 4th, 2010 at 10:56am #

    I concur with your description of Russia. Russia is a kind of a NATO state without – as yet – the NATO membership and it follows the zionazi diktat – in Larov’s words: it “is fullfilling its international obligations”, ie aiding the zionazis in their plans of distruction and domination of (not only) the muslim world. The same could be said of India. And China is slowly but steadily becoming a subservient member of the zionazified “international community…

  25. Josie Michel-Bruening said on November 5th, 2010 at 8:25am #

    I want to agree to Kim Petersen, and concerning the Chinese human right abuses, I want to add: No American politician and no European one has the right for pointing on China as human right abuser as long as prisoners in Guantanamo, Bagran, Abu Ghraib and secretly in European countries are tortured or by European supported flights taking prisoners into countries where torture of prisoners is not forbidden.
    The actual “crime” of China or that of less important countries as Cuba seem to be that they want to protect their borders and maintain their territorial integrity and the sovereignty of their country.
    What is motivating US politicians when fighting against Islam and allegedly for democracy: nothing else but greedy expansionism, I guess, in an attitude of social darwinism or still worse “friendly” fascism.

  26. mary said on November 6th, 2010 at 2:28am #

    Chomsky on the election.

    ‘That incorrigible 18th-century radical Adam Smith, speaking of England, observed that the principal architects of power were the owners of the society—in his day the merchants and manufacturers—and they made sure that government policy would attend scrupulously to their interests, however “grievous” the impact on the people of England; and worse, on the victims of “the savage injustice of the Europeans” abroad.’

    He omits to say who the current ‘owners’ are however.

    http://inthesetimes.com/article/6615/outrage_misguided/

  27. Josie Michel-Bruening said on November 6th, 2010 at 8:18am #

    Hi, Mary,
    I read the article by Noam Chomsky you mentioned above.
    I think Noam Chomsky is perfectly right when saing at the end:

    …The American Petroleum Institute, backed by the Chamber of Commerce and the other business lobbies, has intensified its efforts to persuade the public to dismiss concerns about anthropogenic global warming—with considerable success, as polls indicate. Among Republican congressional candidates in the 2010 election, virtually all reject global warming.

    The executives behind the propaganda know that global warming is real, and our prospects grim. But the fate of the species is an externality that the executives must ignore, to the extent that market systems prevail. And the public won’t be able to ride to the rescue when the worst-case scenario unfolds.
    I am just old enough to remember those chilling and ominous days of Germany’s descent from decency to Nazi barbarism, to borrow the words of Fritz Stern, the distinguished scholar of German history. In a 2005 article, Stern indicates that he has the future of the United States in mind when he reviews “a historic process in which resentment against a disenchanted secular world found deliverance in the ecstatic escape of unreason.”

    I am an old German woman, born in that “descent from decency of Nazi barbarism” and having learned by my parents and teachers about how it began.
    Although, Chomsky adds history would be too complex as to repeat exactly I wished those being responsible for the current disaster would read his article and study European history then to compare it with nowadays.