Without Bold Action America Will Relive
the Influenza Pandemic of 1918
by Gene C. Gerard
www.dissidentvoice.org
November 23, 2005



 

Last week President Bush promoted his program to prepare America for a bird flu pandemic at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Summit. In his comments Mr. Bush noted, “If history is our guide there’s reason to be concerned.” In fact, the influenza pandemic of 1918 is a model for what we are likely to face with the bird flu. And unless the Bush administration responds more boldly we will relive the 1918 pandemic, only this time it will be worse.

The pandemic of 1918 is believed to have killed 675,000 Americans, more than the American casualties of World War I, World War II, the Korean War, and the war in Vietnam combined. It’s estimated that the current flu strain would kill millions of Americans. Dr. Michael Osterholm, an epidemiologist at the University of Minnesota, has called the bird flu pandemic “the single greatest risk to our world today.” Considering the potential fatalities, the $7.1 billion that Mr. Bush has requested to combat a potential pandemic is woefully inadequate.

Over $300 billion has been funded to date to fight the war in Iraq. The Pentagon is spending more than $10 billion to research and develop a ballistic missile defense system that many experts have said will not even be effective. And the Pentagon spent $4.5 billion this year to study the possibility of designing a new tactical aircraft. It’s clear that the budget priorities of the Bush administration are seriously askew.

The bird flu strain is believed to be nearly identical to the virus that caused the influenza pandemic of 1918. Typically, a flu virus destroys the cells lining the upper respiratory tract, resulting in its victims succumbing to pneumonia. However, the flu in 1918, which originated in birds on the Kansas plains, destroyed the tissue of the lungs. This prompted an immune response reaction in which the lungs filled up with secretions, drowning those infected. Virologists believe the bird flu strain operates in the same manner.

Of the $7.1 billion that Mr. Bush has proposed spending on pandemic preparedness, $1.2 billion has been slated to purchase enough vaccine to inoculate 20 million Americans. But this would only protect 14 percent of the nation.  The administration proposes spending another $2.8 billion to develop a vaccine against the bird flu once it mutates into a virus capable of directly infecting humans.

The goal is to produce enough vaccine for every American within six months of a pandemic outbreak. Yet Dr. Margaret Chan, the director of pandemic flu preparedness for the World Health Organization, recently cautioned that there would only be at best three weeks to contain a local outbreak before it begins to spread globally. And Secretary of Health and Human Services Michael Levitt has admitted that it will not be feasible for the government to create a significant number of vaccinations until 2010. 

The administration proposes spending $1 billion to stockpile anti-viral drugs. The administration believes these drugs might lessen the length and severity of a flu infection. But the Director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Julie Gerberding, contradicted this assertion, stating, “There is no evidence that it will make a difference if we are hit with a pandemic.” It make’s more sense to put this funding toward purchasing or developing vaccines.

A bird flu pandemic is a threat to the armed services and our national security. Since soldiers are serving an average of two tours of duty in Iraq they would almost certainly carry the bird flu to the Middle East. In 1918 it was soldiers serving in World War I who brought the virus to Europe. And because they lived in close quarters, as they do today, a disproportionate number of soldiers died in 1918 and 1919.

The influenza pandemic of 1918 first appeared at Fort Riley, Kansas when an Army cook reported to the infirmary with head and muscle aches, a sore throat, and fever. Later that same day over 100 soldiers were complaining of similar symptoms. Within a week over 500 soldiers at Fort Riley had come down with the flu.

In September 1918 Dr. Victor Vaughn, the Acting Surgeon General of the U.S. Army, visited an Army base near Boston to access the pandemic.  He found “hundreds of young men in uniform coming into the wards of the hospital. A cough brought up the blood-stained sputum. In the morning, the dead bodies are stacked about the morgue like cordwood.” Today, sick and weakened soldiers in Iraq would be much more vulnerable than they already are.

The program that President Bush put forward is inadequate at best. The budgetary priorities of the administration should be shifted such that significantly more funding is allocated to prepare for the coming pandemic. Richard Falkenrath, a former advisor to the Homeland Security Department, recently noted that, “A flu pandemic is the most dangerous threat the United States faces today. It’s a bigger threat than terrorism.” The Bush administration must act accordingly.

Gene C. Gerard teaches American history at a small college in suburban Dallas, and is a contributing author to the forthcoming book Americana at War. His previous articles have appeared in Dissident Voice, Political Affairs Magazine, The Free Press, Intervention Magazine, The Modern Tribune, and The Palestine Chronicle. He can be reached at: genecgerard@comcast.net.

Other Articles by Gene C. Gerard

* Any Soldier Will Do For the Pentagon
* Kansas Attorney General is Bush’s Kind of Guy
* VA Seeks to Punish Iraq War Veterans
* Soldiers Shouldn’t Serve as Police Officers
* Republicans Require Health Insurance for Immigrants Only
* Poverty Increases as Incomes Decline Under President Bush
* As in World War II, The President Should Limit Oil Profits
* Supreme Court Nominee John G. Roberts and the Voting Rights Act
* The Flag Should Not Infringe on the First Amendment
* President Bush Must Address Outsourcing
* Consumer Confidence Decline Surprises Only the Bush Administration
* Conservative Ideology Hinders U.S. AIDS Policy
* The Record of Judge John Roberts
* Gay Marriage Critics Are Misguided
* Democrats Can Succeed Without the Filibuster
* Turkey is Not a Role Model for the Middle East
* Violations of Civil Liberties are an American Tradition
* The Economy Turned the Corner and Is Headed in the Wrong Direction
* Bush Administration Promotes Global Conflicts by Rewarding Allies
* Bush Administration Attempts to Influence Global HIV/AIDS Policy
* Conservatives, Judicial Impeachment, and Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas
* Appeals Court Nominee Janice Rogers Brown Merits the Filibuster
* Zimbabwe’s Very American Election
* Appeals Court Nominee Thomas B. Griffith is a Poor Choice
* President Bush’s Use of Pardons Isn’t Very Compassionate
* E.P.A. Nominee Supports Testing of Chemicals on Human Subjects
* Military Policy on Gays is Costly and Dangerous
* Bush Administration AIDS Policies Continue to Fall Short
* Bush’s Judicial Nominations are Hardly Mainstream
* Bush’s Budget is at Odds With His Rhetoric
* Iraq’s Election Will Not Guarantee Democracy
* The Politics of SpongeBob

HOME