(DV) Kurth: Of Bibles and Guns

FREE hit counter and Internet traffic statistics from freestats.com

HOME

NEWS SERVICE

LETTERS

ABOUT DV

CONTACT

SUBMISSIONS

Of Bibles and Guns
by Peter Kurth
www.dissidentvoice.org
December 17, 2005

Don’t ask me to explain why I’m still on my “religion” kick -- three columns in a row, all about “God.” Maybe it’s the season -- you know, the “holidays.” (Oh, excuse me, I mean Christmas, of course! And New Year’s. And Hanukkah, and Kwanzaa, and “shopping,” and whatever else they might dream up for the solstice in the interest of making money.)

Anyway, I’m still on that kick. Probably I’ve turned to religion because I can’t stand the thought of reading, never mind writing, another word about George W. Bush. Not before Lent, anyway. We’ll see what happens after that.

I understand that Bush’s “approval ratings” have bumped up slightly -- not much, but a little -- since he embarked on his manly “Strategy for Victory” campaign in Iraq. Don’t worry: They’ll fall back where they belong when people get their heating bills this winter.

So it’s “religion” again. Two stories caught my eye last week, sitting calmly side-by-side in the local daily. One of them concerned the statement of the president of Iran that Israel “should be moved to Europe” (which would be like moving Killington to New Hampshire, only racist). And the other was about that man in Brazil, Rayfran das Nevas Sales, who is “accused of killing the American nun and rain forest defendant Dorothy Stang” -- shooting her dead last February, in fact, “with six shots from a .38-caliber revolver,” in the belief (as Sales now tells the courts) “that he acted in self-defense after mistaking her Bible for a gun.” Stang was 73. The story explained:

“Sales testified he and Stang had an argument over who owned the land he was working, and that Stang threatened to 'finish him off' with the help of some 150 people living on a sustainable development reserve.

“She said, “The weapon I have is this,” and reached into her bag,” Sales said. 'I didn’t know what she was going to pull out of her bag, so I shot her.'”

Now, I think it’s a weak defense, and I don’t think it’ll work. (It only works for governments.) But I’d be the last person -- with no disrespect to Sister Stang -- to dispute that the Bible, very often, does assume the aspect of a gun. And however noble her mission, however sincere her beliefs, we can’t just go tramping into other people’s worlds and expect them to get “good” all of a sudden. On our terms.

Call it a “culture clash” -- call it whatever you want. But “Beware the people of the Book,” as Gore Vidal remarks. By “Book” Vidal means bibles, whether they’re Christian, Muslim, or Jewish. Vidal is a well-known smart-aleck -- thank you, Gore! -- yet his words bear hearing:

The great unmentionable evil at the center of our culture is monotheism. From a barbaric Bronze Age text known as the Old Testament, three anti-human religions have evolved -- Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. These are sky-god religions. They are, literally, patriarchal -- God is the Omnipotent Father . . . He requires total obedience from everyone on earth, as he is not just in place for one tribe, but for all creation. Those who would reject him must be converted or killed for their own good.

So, who got killed? In this case, Sister Stang, but it could just as easily have been Sales -- let’s say, if he’d come forward before shooting a gentle nun and said, “Guess what? I don’t buy it.” And the point is not that his legal defense is in any way defensible; rather, as Vidal repeats, that these “sky-god” religions, historically, have been the bane of the earth. Every war, every terror, every torture, every persecution since the conversion of Rome under Emperor Constantine can be traced, ultimately, to them. Even Marx and the horrors of communism can be traced to them. Because Marx had a “Book,” too -- Das Kapital -- a kind of “anti”-Book, but a Book nonetheless. Or maybe I mean Hitler and Mein Kampf. We all know what transpired from that. Indeed, we’re proud of ourselves for defeating it. Aren’t we?

Consider again the words of the Iranian president, who thinks that Israel should be “moved to Europe. [The Jews] faced injustice in Europe, so why do the repercussions fall on the Palestinians?” It’s an honest question, but it ignores all reason, all reality, and all fact. Israel exists, and it’s going to keep on existing right where it is, as it should, and must. And at least in Judaism you're allowed to shake your fist at the Deity. But so long as everyone is huddled over their Korans and their Torahs and their “Testaments” there will be no peace. It’s forbidden. It’s out of the question. It’s ironic, even, when you understand that they’re all really the same religion -- “sky-god” things. This is what Vidal means.

Now we’ve got The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe -- “Narnia” -- a big Hollywood hype that pretends to be a fairy tale like any other but is actually a Christian exegesis, a metaphor of the suffering of Christ, with all the phony magic our other “Books” pretend to confirm. Who knows -- maybe it’s a good movie. But it’s only a movie, and you ignore that at your peril. Its original author, C. S. Lewis, was an Oxford don with an exalted nature, who had a particular, prissy, British-style penchant for being punished. Lewis thought -- and said -- that if The Narnia Chronicles were ever filmed, they should be done as cartoons. And he was right.

Oh -- I almost forgot to add: Merry “Season”.

Peter Kurth is the author of international bestselling books including: Anastasia: The Riddle of Anna Anderson, Isadora: A Sensational Life, and a biography of the anti-fascist journalist Dorothy Thompson, American Cassandra: The Life of Dorothy Thompson. His essays have appeared in Salon, Vanity Fair, New York Times Book Review, and many others. Peter lives in Burlington, Vermont. He can be reached at: peterkurth@peterkurth.com. Visit his website at: www.peterkurth.com/