Executions Not Leading to Reconciliation

BAGHDAD, Nov 22 (IPS) – The executions of former regime officials are creating greater division, rather than reconciliation, among Iraqis.

Special courts formed by the American occupation authorities in Iraq are issuing death sentences — like that carried out on former Iraqi President Saddam Hussein, on 30 December 2006 — on what many Iraqis are interpreting as a political basis.

“Executing Saddam cost Iraqis a lot of hatred and more division between the sects, ” Walid Al-Ubaidi, post-graduate law student at Baghdad University told IPS.

“Now they [U.S.-backed Iraqi Government] are executing the Ex-Minister of Defense, Sultan Hashim Ahmed, who was very well known for being a professional general who led the Iraqi army against Iran,” Al-Ubaidi said, stressing that, “This man represents a symbol for the Iraqi army that defended Iraq.”

On 24 June 2007 the Iraqi High Tribunal found Ahmed guilty of presiding over the killing of thousands of Kurds during the Anfal campaign in the 1980s.

Several legal delays, and more recently a delay for a religious holiday, have postponed the execution.

A clerk in the court where Ahmed and a number of his generals were sentenced spoke with IPS on condition of anonymity. He asked to be referred to as Hassan.

“We were surprised by the sentence,” Hassan told IPS in Baghdad, “This general was no more than a government official who carried out orders with notable skill and proficiency.”

“What makes us better than any of those we called dictators and war criminals?” Hassan asked.

“These generals were the ones who defeated Iran in the war and so [Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri] Al-Maliki and his American masters want to punish them in order to please the Iranian Ayatollahs,” former Iraqi army colonel Saad Abbas told IPS in Baghdad.

Anger against the U.S. occupation for the sentences has also been aroused because of the promise for asylum the general was given before he surrendered to U.S. military forces.

“They promised him asylum and that was why he surrendered to them in peace,” a relative of the general, speaking on condition of anonymity, told IPS.

“They even asked him to take a post in the new system, but he refused, and maybe that is why they sold him to his enemies,” the relative said.

An Iraqi resistance fighter spoke with IPS on condition of strict anonymity.

“We are not happy for this man’s execution, but we believe it was his fault to trust the Americans,” he said. “He should have known, as a general who negotiated with them more than once, how bad they were. Moreover, he should have joined the resistance against occupation rather than surrender to his dirty enemies.”

“This man and his colleagues represent the army that terrified those Arab tyrants in an Arab neighboring country,” Thuraya Shamil, an engineer from Baghdad Municipality told IPS.

“They cannot forget the day that they ran out of their palaces like rats,” Shamil emphasised.

Others view the situation differently, but still agree that the generals do not deserve to be sentenced to death.

“At the moment we are looking for solutions to the dilemma of internal divisions, comes these sentences to widen the gaps between sects and groups,” Malik Nazar, a member of the Iraqi Dialogue Front that has nine MPs in the Iraqi Parliament, told IPS.

“We must stop sacrificing our men for the sake of sending messages of compassion to Iran and others who have feuds with our heroic army men,” Nazar stressed.

“They are killing any Sunni Arab who might one day lead Iraqis, or at least a group of Iraqis, when this dirty occupation leaves the country,” Ali Salman, a teacher in Baghdad, told IPS, “As long as Iranians and Kurds are our real rulers, all our good men will always be targeted.”

Ali al-Fadhily is an IPS correspondent in Baghdad who works in close collaboration with Dahr Jamail, a U.S.-based specialist writer on Iraq who travels extensively in the region. Read other articles by Ali, or visit Ali's website.

3 comments on this article so far ...

Comments RSS feed

  1. Mike McNiven said on November 26th, 2007 at 12:37am #

    Thank you Mr.Fadhily for showing one more aspect of US/UK crimes in Iraq!
    The supporters of the “Persian Talibans” are not going to like your piece. ( the Israeli foreign ministry is not going to like it either, it sounds complicated, but it is not!) :

    “These generals were the ones who defeated Iran in the war and so [Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri] Al-Maliki and his American masters want to punish them in order to please the Iranian Ayatollahs,” former Iraqi army colonel Saad Abbas told IPS in Baghdad.

  2. Shabnam said on November 27th, 2007 at 1:41pm #

    Mr. al-Fadhily wrote:
    “These generals were the ones who defeated Iran in the war and so [Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri] Al-Maliki and his American masters want to punish them in order to please the Iranian Ayatollahs,” former Iraqi army colonel Saad Abbas told IPS in Baghdad.”

    Iran was not defeated by Iraq. Saddam a puppet of the west, was let into power by Americans after murdering Abdul Karim Ghassim, a nationalist, by this puppet, Saddam, who played an important role by waging an American War against Iran but finally he was destroyed by those who supported his dictatorship and provided him with Weapon of Mass destruction funded by the Puppet Arab heat of States for 8 years to kill a million of Iranian youth and to bombard Iranian cities and used chemical weapon against Iranians – provided by the imperial and colonial west – to kill more than 50,000 of Iranian youths by chemical weapon alone yet Iran was not defeated. The Arab puppet head of states can not wash their pettiness which has brought so much SHAME for the Arab population as a whole and can not use this kind of rhetoric against Iran to hide their own services to imperialist/Zionist camp against the interest of their people and the people of the region.

    The Arab “intellectuals” MUST wake up and stop supporting the imperialist/Zionist project called “the greater Middle east” which is nothing but colonization of the region with Israel having the upper hand. Arab “intellectuals” must direct their frustration, anger and humiliation towards their REAL enemy, imperial/Zionist, and not against a country where has suffered and continue to suffer at the hand of the war criminals who are willing to use “nuclear holocaust” to expand their influence to rob people of the region. The Arab
    “intellectuals” must realize that Iran is not their enemy and watch for those Zionists, who disguise themselves as pro Arab by writing:

    “Thank you Mr. Fadhily for showing one more aspect of US/UK crimes in Iraq! The supporters of the “Persian Talibans” are not going to like your piece. (The Israeli Foreign ministry is not going to like it either, it sounds complicated, but it is not!):

    Only the Zionist pro Israel would write such nonsense. The word “Persian” is repeatedly used by Zionists to put Iranian people against each other and creates Majority over minorities, like tribe of Kurdistan, to bribe their leaders to spy and cooperate towards destabilization and to divide the courtiers of the region, like what they did to ottoman empire, and plan to do it in Iraq, Sudan, Iran and elsewhere to create a different map of the middle east for the benefit of an illegitimate state, Israel, and for the expansion of sphere of influence of the West and control of the resources.
    Mr. al-Fadhily you must distinguish your real enemy from the enemy that Zionists want you to see. I hope Arabs, Iranians, Turks and other people of the region push aside their petty differences and focus on the enemy of all, the imperial west who has implemented a colonial plan, robbing Palestrina of their land by the Zionists, to put one group against the other while they are expanding their presence and their influence by occupation and mass murdering of the people. I hope the Arab “intellectuals” will stop deionization of “Persian” as their masters want them to do, especially the Israeli” and create genuine cooperation with the population of the neighboring countries and create a united front against the real enemy.
    Please watch those who disguise themselves as an Iranian opposition who tries to deceive you by Using “Persian Taliban”. It is obvious that he does know Persian since he is not Iranian but his mission is to demonize Iran like true Zionists.

  3. Mike McNiven said on November 29th, 2007 at 1:13pm #

    http://www.we4change.info/english/