Egypt – The Peoples’ Voices

Civil disobedience is not our problem. Our problem is civil obedience. Our problem is that people are obedient all over the world in the face of poverty and starvation and stupidity, and war, and cruelty.

— Howard Zinn (1922-2010)

Arguably never has a momentous event, its triumphs and blood soaked tragedies, been so instantly transmitted across the globe, panicking governments, bent on quelling it, inspiring millions with similar aspirations to Egypt’s populus, into “can do” and unstinting support mode, with, literally, a vengeance.

The first act of Egypt’s regime was to put an end to this extraordinary avalanche of people to people’s freedom of information – and pull the plug. It failed. The internet generation is a young people’s domain. Like wildfire, instructions instantly flew around the net, informing those with contacts in Egypt, the prefixes which would circumvent the cut off. “Anonymous”, a “hacktivist” group, promptly brought down systems still working in Egypt – those of government offices.

Al Jazeera also reported: “After internet services were disconnected in Egypt, protesters were prevented from speaking to the world. But thanks to John Scott Railton, a Los Angeles based student, who took upon himself the task of uploading messages on micro blogging site twitter (information is still making its way online.) He started making calls and posting messages on a twitter account he created for the Egyptian protests.”

Vodaphone was reportedly pressured by the Egyptian government to send pro-Mubrak texts to all its subscribers in the country. Gathering by the global net traffic about this, it may well cost the company dearly.

The immediacy of information, and the reason for governmental panic (surely mirrored, especially in those great democratic bastions, Washington and Whitehall, already mooting limiting the internet – or worse – and the delusionally self- styled “only democracy in the Middle East”, Israel) can be seen by trawling the messages. Power can no longer mask reality. No spin can obscure message deluge, traversing the globe, by the second.

Just few of these, near randomly garnered from friends and contacts in Egypt, late yesterday and early today, are an example of the passion, defiance, courage, hope – some will say naivety – in eloquent brevity. They are written as sent:

“CAIRO Right now its all calm and the crowd is holding the square chanting WE WILL NOT LEAVE … tomorrow is The Friday of Departure !!”

” We are not leaving – we are ready to die here – Please tell the world to pray for us.”

“We do not want help from obama or any one we will take our freedom by our self.”

“heavy gunfire heard in Tahrir Square.”

“Friend’s neighbor’s family just received corpse of their son, arrested a few days ago.”

“Israel has offered to place ‘all its capabilities” at the hands of General Omar Suleiman, the recently appointed Vice President of Egypt, for the ‘protection of the regime of Egypt.’ Israeli Prime Minister   Netanyahu suggested intelligence personnel undertaking specialist operations to bring an end to demonstrations.”

“Man with a camera wearing a blue “Press” vest, being beaten on the street. The army stepped in and fire shots in air to disperse the crowd, the man was led away.”

“Two Al Jazeera reporters have just been attacked on their way from airport to central Cairo – more updates soon.”

“Shahira Amin resigned from Nile TV because of their coverage of the protests – she spoke live to Al Jazeera. She was the deputy head of the station.”

“Come what may, I am here with the people…. I am not scared.” Shahira Amin (Egyptian TV reporter)–Deputy head of NILE TV station resigned in protest of the biased pro-govt reporting. She is now in Tahrir square. She said: “I refuse to be part of the propaganda machine.”

” … a British freelance journalist in Cairo, says foreigners have had to go into hiding: ‘Anyone who is a journalist has been attacked, and if you’re a foreigner the same problem is happening. I have now had to move into hiding, keeping away from windows, keeping away from any of the action and reducing my visibility online.'”

“From Jack (who is cautious reporter): ‘Al Arabiya reporting from Cairo that a foreign journalist has been beaten to death. I am not going out there to confirm it.'”

“this is people’s power. This democracy from below. This is the most beautiful thing i have ever seen in my life.”

“there is now replacement for the front teams that finished defending the frontline.”

“the injured  treated here by volunteering doctors. We took 6 oct bridge too. Thugs retreating ..”

“… at Abdel Moneim Riyadh sq. This is the frontline now. A mini clinic set up by the Barricades.”

“Protesters and army watched as a man stood on the bridge, got paid, got out rifle, shot a protester in the head and walked away.”

“Urgent, urgent, urgent. Democracy activists need medicines, first aid, water, food, direct access to media, please advertise and demand action, not empty words. Thank you.” By-pass numbers for circumventing the block were posted back again, instantly.

“Please spare a thought for the people of Gaza.The border has been closed now for five days.

“Tomorrow’s demonstrations against the Israeli Separation Wall in the occupied West Bank villages of Bil’in, Ni’lin, Nabi Saleh and Al-Ma’sara will be in solidarity with the Egyptian people. Those demonstrations usually  take place after Friday prayers.”

“Mubarak armed goons have kidnapped Aljazeera’s producer, Mysa  khalaf  al-tawil (daughter of dear friend Kamal).  Mysa just arrived in Cairo two days ago to help in the coverage for the channel.  I urge all of you if you can help to obtain her release or to provide information that could help in locating her.  Please spread the message and inform me if you learn anything.  Add this to the list of crimes for the Mubarak regime.  It is personal now.”

“By the way the energetic and hard-working Aljazeera’s producer, Mysa Khalaf Al-Tawil is an American citizen. Will the US government work hard to obtain her release? If she was kidnapped by Revolutionary Guards in Iran, the US government would have ordered a bombing campaign against Iran by now.” ((Updates: Angry Arab News Service))

“Christians protecting Muslims in prayer during protests.”

“Gunfire in Tahrir Square.”

“Many Judges involved in demonstration ..”

“Of the charge by arms wielding “opposition” (later found to have police identity cards on them) who streamed through the Square on horses and camels:”

“Those horse and camel cavalry will never stop the power of the people. Sound of the people is God (sic) sound.”

“I swear to God there are more than twenty people dead.”

Tweeted: “soldier ostensibly crying, being comforted by a demonstrator who has a stethoscope round his neck.” There are several, so far, non-verifiable reports, that this is the young soldier so conflicted between loyalty to the people and his profession that he sat atop his tank and put his gun in his mouth, but was persuaded to instead, jump down.

“URGENT, EGYPT: URGENT help needed for a 1st aid station by Tahrir Square-pass to anyone you know in Cairo who can help-Mohamed Mahmod at Bab El Louq near Tahrir is in URGENT need of Alcohol, Betadine (antiseptic), Water (mineral), Plastic gloves, garbage gloves, plastic dishes, cotton, any old tshirts, anti-biotics, painkillers, Shaash (gauze). If you have contacts please call or text +2 012-240-6441”

“Mubarak supporters are storming Cairo hotels looking for journalists.”

“Between 8 and 12 human rights lawyers arrested at Hisham Mubarak Law Centre.”

Sandmonkey” is possibly Egypt’s most famous blogger : “Breaking news: @Sandmonkey arrested by state security. They called his father & claimed he has revolution leaflets #Egypt.”

“want to see ‘the land of the free and the home of the brave’? Go to Egypt. 2 million already at Tahrir Square – knowing that what happened yesterday (of knives and bullets …) can happen again”

“Imam talked about Christ and Mohammed, their teachings and relating it to oppression. I came across two nuns.”

“Eslam Bakir?born March 1, 1989?degree: BA of Arts in European Culture, 2010?killed January 25, 2011 while demonstrating for his people’s freedom?Rest in peace, brave young man.”

(25th January was Day One of the extraordinary, spontaneous, resistance.)

“Message to PJ Crowley: . @PJCrowley US can prevent a massacre by egyptian army which depends solely on US for funds – pull funding now or US will be responsible.” (PJ Crowley: Assistant Secretary, US Bureau of Public Affairs.)

Rabbi Michael Lerner: ‘We hope that Egyptians will hear the news that they have strong support from many in the Jewish world. We are not waffling like Obama – we want the overthrow of Mubarak, the freeing of all political prisoners, the redistribution of wealth in a fair way, trials for those who perpetrated torture and other forms of injustice, and the democratisation of all aspects of Egyptian life.”

Early Friday, the: “Day of Departure”:  ?”Tahrir Square has free food and drinks, a bandstand with live music, dedicated medical staff and a sense of community which Mubarak’s opponents say makes them proud of their country  for the first time in decades.”

“Actually one of the mothers just kicked the ass of one of the guys of tried to stop us from joining the protests!!”

” ‘The US won’t dictate a foreign country’s policy.’ Damn, don’t let the people of Iraq, Afghanistan & Pakistan hear that #Egypt.”

On Thursday, that canny, journalistic, Middle East political barometer, Robert Fisk, referred to Egyptian leader Hosni Mubarak not as President, but “President.” The writing, seemingly, is at least visible on Cairo’s walls, ancient and modern.

The man he dubbed Lord Blair of Kut Al Amara (site of the spectacular British defeat in Iraq in 1916) lurking as “Middle East Peace Envoy”, in Jerusalem, has not failed in his seemingly, near medically delusional assessments, now of Egypt’s murderous leader. He is, declared Blair: “Immensely courageous and a force for good.”

“An American correspondent: ‘While Egypt burns, our “president” makes us “proud” This morning on air talking about prayer and the nature of Christianity – all while anxiously awaiting the arrival of Jennifer Lopez and hubbie to watch the Super Bowl with him. Words fail.’ ”

One can only echo Fisk, again, who watching the “pro-Mubarak demonstrators”, one with bright red eyes and all seemingly motivated by something more than fresh air: “What are they on?”

For additional information click here.

Felicity Arbuthnot is a journalist with special knowledge of Iraq. Author, with Nikki van der Gaag, of Baghdad in the Great City series for World Almanac books, she has also been Senior Researcher for two Award winning documentaries on Iraq, John Pilger's Paying the Price: Killing the Children of Iraq and Denis Halliday Returns for RTE (Ireland.) Read other articles by Felicity.

18 comments on this article so far ...

Comments RSS feed

  1. bozh said on February 4th, 2011 at 10:28am #

    i expected that ?all ‘democracies’ wld turn against protesters. unfortunately, they have all the military hardware!
    and i do not expect that rulers in ‘democracies’ will use sanity to resolve the issue. tnx

  2. Deadbeat said on February 4th, 2011 at 2:41pm #

    What’s wrong with this picture …

    Egypt – The Peoples’ Voices

    The nameless voice are inspiring but where names are used the author cites two soft Zionists — Howard Zinn and Micheal Lerner.

  3. mary said on February 4th, 2011 at 2:42pm #

    The people’s voices are not allowed to be heard in Palestine. The Israeli stooges, the Palesinian Authority, is running scared of the same outpouring of condemnation.


    PS I see that there is more of Bozh’s defeatist stuff here.

  4. Deadbeat said on February 4th, 2011 at 2:49pm #

    mary writes …
    PS I see that there is more of Bozh’s defeatist stuff here.

    I totally agree. What’s going on in Egypt is a national liberation movement to restore Arab pride and dignity and a movement against Zionist tyranny that has retarded Arab economic development and suppress Arab aspiration in the service of Zionist supremacy.

    The pseudo-Left is appears NOT to inspired by these events and IMO primarily concerned of the fallout to Zionism by this Arab revolution that has spread throughout the Middle East.

  5. Rehmat said on February 4th, 2011 at 3:17pm #

    Noam Chmosky admitted on ‘Democracy Now!’ a few days ago that the reason the US, Israel and Saudi Arabia fear democracy in the Arab countries – is because they know what will be the result of a fair democratic election – anti-Israel Islamist parties will come in power – as it happened in PA Territories, Lebanon, Iraq and Iran.

  6. jayn0t said on February 4th, 2011 at 3:27pm #

    Chomsky on Egypt in the Guardian:

  7. commoner3 said on February 4th, 2011 at 4:21pm #

    Not too fast!
    The ONLY well organised and well funded opposition group in Egypt is the Muslim Brotherhood. They are reactionary organisation that wants to transform Egypt into an Islamic Theocracy. They talk democracy and all that bullshitting until they get to power and then they will show their ugly teeth and there will be repression and brutalities againt any opposition comapered what happened in Iran after the Mullahs took over. The Shah repression is dwarfed but what the Mullahs did.
    It is in the interest of Israel that the Arab Societies become reactionary theocratic societies INSTEAD of secular modern societies.
    Israel nutured and helped Hamas to grow and now the Palestinian People is divided and instead of fighting the Israelis they are fighting each other.
    Hamas gave the Israelis the excuse to destroy Gaza and cripple big segment of the Palestinian people institutions and organizations.
    I am not supporting or defending Abbas and do not forget that the ONLY supper power in the world today is the USA, and it and the EU are behindIsreal 100% and that limits the options for any player in the International arena.
    Yes, Mubarak stayed too long he should have gone la long time ago, but immediate “transition” will lead to the Muslim Brotherhood taking over.
    He should plan the transition by giving the leadership to a General from the army, or someone is supported by the army, because the army is the only force that can stand against the Muslim Brotherhood.
    Forger about that “democracy” nonsense. Democracy will not work in Egypt and will lead to chaos and anarch and instability.

  8. Deadbeat said on February 4th, 2011 at 4:25pm #

    Not just “U.S., Israel, and Saudi Arabia” but pseudo-Leftists as well. Here is one such quote “voicing concern” …

    If [“moderates” aka Zionist quisling do not take power if] that happens (and using the Iranian experience as a template), then the way for more extreme religious elements opens wider.

    The fear of the pseudo-Left is a revolution in the Middle East against Zionism. Such a revolution may spread and I hope eventually to the United States.

  9. commoner3 said on February 4th, 2011 at 4:31pm #

    Rahmat wrote:
    ” is because they know what will be the result of a fair democratic election – anti-Israel Islamist parties will come in power – as it happened in PA Territories, Lebanon, Iraq and Iran.
    Really. So you like what is happening in Iraq now by Shia Death squads and the continuous Sini suicide bombing and the destruction and killings that resulted.
    Do you like what happened in Gaza.
    Do you like the destruction and loss of life that happened to Lebanon?
    What planet are living in or what kind of weed you are smoking?

    ” anti-Israel Islamist parties will come in power – as it happened in PA Territories, Lebanon, Iraq and Iran.

  10. Deadbeat said on February 4th, 2011 at 4:48pm #


    Isn’t the United States still occupying Iraq? Isn’t Zionist dominance upheld by the United States still the underlying factor?

  11. commoner3 said on February 4th, 2011 at 5:03pm #

    Re: Deadbeat said on February 4th, 2011 at 4:48pm #

    Deadbeat wrote:
    “Isn’t the United States still occupying Iraq? Isn’t Zionist dominance upheld by the United States still the underlying factor?
    Yes, definitely. Yes absolutely, but Rehmant calls the Shia theorcratic government installed by the US is the result of a “fair and democratic election”??!!! Go figure.

  12. kalidasa said on February 4th, 2011 at 8:00pm #

    John (he weighed the same when he left as when he went in) McCain got right down to official Israeli business..

  13. jayn0t said on February 4th, 2011 at 8:54pm #

    This article in the New York Times: – worries about “Egypt’s obligations to Israel”. And America’s too.

  14. Deadbeat said on February 5th, 2011 at 1:08am #

    The Chomsky article was a rambling incoherent piece. Also Chomsky tries to water down the aid to Israel & Egypt (which is essentially aid to Israel) , with the inclusion of the bribes to Tunisia — a mere $5 million.

    A National Liberation Movement, an overthrow of Zionist tyranny, by Egypt, such perspectives are clearly missing from Chomsky.

  15. mary said on February 5th, 2011 at 2:49am #

    Another voice of the people writes.

    Mubarak’s Last Gasps – Esam Al-Amin

    There are decades when nothing happens; and there are weeks when decades happen.”
    –V. I. Lenin (1870-1924)

    “Victory is accomplished through the perseverance of the last hour.”
    –Prophet Muhammad (570-632 AD)

    February 04, 2011 According to the CIA’s declassified documents and records, senior CIA operative, Kermit Roosevelt, paid $100,000 to mobsters in Tehran, in early August 1953, to hire the most feared thugs to stage pro-Shah riots.

    Other CIA-paid men were brought weeks later, on August 19, into Tehran in buses and trucks to take over the streets, topple the democratically elected Iranian government, and restore Shah Reza Pahlavi to his thrown. It took the people of Iran 26 years, enormous sacrifices, and a popular revolution to overthrow the imposed, corrupt and repressive rule of the Shah.


    The evil is beyond words and is the creation largely of the Judaeo-‘Christian’ alliance and human greed for money and power. As one reads on, one’s mind turns to the rise of fascism here. The well- fed babyface of the UK PM Cameron has been speaking in Munich this morning and he has been quoted all night by the ZBC who obviously were provided with an advance copy.

    Hitler and the Reichstag come to mind.{}

    He spoke of the failure of ”multi-culturalism’ and the need for ‘muscular liberalism’. Islam OK BUT IT IS THE EXTREMISTS WE NEED TO ISOLATE. Straight anti-Islamism in order to promote Zionist hegemony in every thing. Meanwhile there are frequent voices about anti-semitic acts in the UK. They are grossly exaggerate. They cannot speak of the brotherhood of man or of our common humanity.

  16. 3bancan said on February 5th, 2011 at 3:52am #

    mary said on February 5th, 2011 at 2:49am #

    “Straight anti-Islamism in order to promote Zionist hegemony in every thing”

    This is its Russian version:
    “Moscow launches Jewish culture classes in detention centers
    Starting next week, inmates awaiting trial at Moscow’s pre-trial detention centers will be able to attend lessons in Jewish culture, the department for cooperation with law-enforcement agencies at the Russian Federation of Jewish Communities reports. The course will be taught by the department’s chief Aaron Gurevich and other workers of Russia’s rabbinate under the agreement for spiritual guidance, executed by the Federation of Jewish Communities and the Federal Penitentiary Service in 2010.

  17. mary said on February 5th, 2011 at 5:35am #

    Hate from the Munchner Sicherheitkonferenz (Munich Security Conference)

    The usual suspects are ALL there. Clinton, McCain, Kissinger and on and on….

    Note Mr Wisner (Obomber’s envoy to Mubarak) has hot footed from Cairo to Munich and will be ‘moderated’ by Nik Gowing of the ZBC.

  18. kalidasa said on February 5th, 2011 at 9:40am #

    Chomsky would have us all believe the Romans crucified Jesus for oil.