Racism in Our Time

Two weeks ago, July 16, marked the one-year anniversary of the arrest of Harvard professor, Henry Louis Gates, by Sgt. James Crowley, a policeman in Cambridge, Massachusetts. On July 1, the findings of an “independent review” of the confrontation that led to the arrest were issued in a press release.

The bare-bones account of what happened is that a woman passerby saw Gates attempting to enter his home in an upscale neighborhood, and thought (presumably because he was African American and appeared to be struggling with the door) that he was a burglar. She called 911. The police arrived and confronted Gates on his front porch. Believing he had been racially profiled, Gates lashed out in defiant indignation.

His outburst got him arrested for disorderly conduct, placed in handcuffs, and taken to the Cambridge police station. Although the matter was eventually sorted out and all charges dropped, the incident triggered numerous responses from African American and human rights groups, and received international coverage.

The episode ended amicably a couple weeks later (July 30) when President Obama invited the white cop and the black professor to join him and Vice-President Biden for a friendly brewski in a shaded courtyard adjacent to the White House Rose Garden. The occasion was instantly nicknamed the “Beer Summit.”

As clumsy and unfortunate as the Gates’ arrest was, the findings of the subsequent investigation — conducted by a 12-person panel composed of “law enforcement personnel, academics, and experts on race relations and conflict resolution,” and chaired by one Charles Wexler — were equally unfortunate.

Astonishingly, after months of careful scrutiny the panel reached the singularly anti-climatic conclusion that the confrontation had been (drumroll, please) “avoidable.”

Sweet Baby Jesus. How was this unedifying bit of glorified committee-speak worthy of a press release? Of course the Gates episode was avoidable. How could it not be avoidable? World War I was avoidable; the invasion of Iraq was avoidable; the assassination of JFK was avoidable; production of the Yugo was avoidable.

Indeed, to conclude that a confrontation was “unavoidable” is to stake out an extreme metaphysical position, one steeped in fatalism and determinism. It’s almost like saying the episode was destined to happen, that it fell outside the boundaries of human influence, which is preposterous. Earthquakes and bad weather are unavoidable. Everything else isn’t.

Gates’ indignation was understandable. Besides being a noted literary critic, professor, editor, and Harvard Ph.D., the man is 60 years old, for crying out loud — not exactly the typical profile of a B&E (breaking and entering) specialist. The cops can stick to their “protect and serve” story all they like, but one has to believe that Gates being black was a determining factor.

Some years ago the CBS show Sixty Minutes did a segment where a white producer telephoned various landlords of apartment buildings to verify that there were still apartments available. But when a well-dressed black man showed up 15 minutes later to rent the apartment, he was told there were no vacancies. When he mentioned the recent phone call, the landlord denied any knowledge of it. This happened repeatedly.

In an episode of Michael Moore’s old television show, TV Nation, they tried a similar experiment. They had a young black man in New York City stand at the curb and attempt to hail a cab. He was repeatedly ignored. The cab drivers simply wouldn’t stop to pick him up.

The producers stationed a white man on the same curb, not far from the black man, and this guy instantly got a ride. It happened repeatedly. They then dressed the black man in a tuxedo. Still no luck. Then they had him in a tuxedo, carrying a large bouquet of flowers. Still no luck. Apparently, even the newly arrived Pakistani cabbies had already learned not to accept the soul brothers as fares.

The show’s producers then — comically, outlandishly — decided to go the limit. They had this black man wearing a tuxedo, holding a bouquet of flowers, and carrying a tiny baby in his arms. Nope, still couldn’t get a ride. Had the spectacle not been such a depressing indictment, it would have been funny.

These examples bring to mind an episode of my own, the memory of which still causes me embarrassment. I was in my car, stopped at a red light at a major intersection, with my window halfway down. The driver of the car on my left lightly honked his horn to get my attention. He was an African American man in his thirties.

With his passenger window down, he politely called out to me, “Can you tell me how to get to Interstate 5?” I was driving a new car, a Honda Accord I had just purchased a few weeks earlier, and still wasn’t familiar with the instruments. My previous car had been an old Volkswagen bug, which had manual roll-down windows.

As I attempted to lower my window, I mistakenly hit the wrong switch. Instead of pressing the power-window button, I hit the door-lock button, automatically locking all four doors.

There was this loud, metallic click-click-click-click sound, which made it appear that I had looked over at this fellow, seen he was African American (“Oh, my God, a Negro!”), and instantly locked all four doors of my vehicle. I still cringe at the memory (in fact, I’m cringing as I type this).

David Macaray is a playwright and author, whose latest book is How to Win Friends and Avoid Sacred Cows: Weird Adventures in India: Hindus, Sikhs, and Muslims When the Peace Corps was New. Everything you ever wanted to know about India but were afraid to ask. He can be reached at: dmacaray@gmail.com. Read other articles by David.

6 comments on this article so far ...

Comments RSS feed

  1. Rehmat said on July 30th, 2010 at 6:12pm #

    Well – American got Afro-Americans, Latinos and Muslims for target shooting of their racism. On the other hand, the Hindu extremists, like the Israeli fanatics – love to practice their hatred towards Muslims and Christians.


  2. lichen said on July 30th, 2010 at 10:10pm #

    You couldn’t use as an example perhaps some of the poor black men who were randomly executed in public by police officers instead of the personal drama of this rich right wing Harvard professor? Really, I’m sick of hearing of that loser.

  3. kalidas said on July 31st, 2010 at 8:00am #

    Rehmat, did you perhaps miss anyone?

  4. yoni said on July 31st, 2010 at 10:50am #

    “…Hindu extremists, like the Israeli fanatics…”

    Indeed, racism in out time

  5. kalidas said on July 31st, 2010 at 11:24am #

    I agree with Rehmat, there are indeed Hindu extremists and Israeli fanatics, and they are at times in kahoots, but they’re not exclusive.

  6. DaveMacaray said on July 31st, 2010 at 12:29pm #

    You all forgot the Turks vs. Armenians, Tutsis vs. Hutus, and surfers vs. the ho-dads. I grant you, there’s lots of animosity in this world—some of it ethnic, some racial, some religious, some nationalistic—I never denied that. But the point of my article was quite specific. It was directed at African Americans.