FREE hit counter and Internet traffic statistics from
(DV) Leopold: Vice President Lied As White House Sought to Defuse Leak Inquiry







Vice President Lied as White House Sought
to Defuse Leak Inquiry

by Jason Leopold
November 7, 2005

Send this page to a friend! (click here)


Did Vice President Dick Cheney help cover up the outing of covert CIA operative Valerie Plame Wilson in the months after conservative columnist Robert Novak first disclosed her identity?

That’s one of the questions Special Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald is likely trying to figure out. It’s unclear what Cheney said to investigators back in 2004 when he was questioned -- not under oath -- about the leak, particularly what he knew and when he knew it.


The five-count criminal indictment handed up by a grand jury last month against Cheney’s former Chief of Staff, I. Lewis “Scooter” Libby, sheds new light on a pattern of strategic deception by the Vice President and the White House to defuse an inquiry into who leaked the name of covert CIA agent Valerie Plame Wilson to the press. Months after Plame’s identity was disclosed by conservative columnist Robert Novak, Cheney continued to hide the fact that he and his aides were intimately involved in disseminating classified information about her to journalists.


What the Vice President denied knowing


The indictment against Cheney’s Chief of Staff, I. Lewis “Scooter” Libby, clearly states that Cheney and Libby discussed Plame’s undercover CIA status and the fact that her husband, former Ambassador Joseph Wilson, traveled to Niger to investigate claims that Iraq tried to acquire yellowcake uranium from the African country in early June of 2003.


Yet the following month, Cheney and then-White House Press Secretary Ari Fleischer asserted that the vice president was unaware of Wilson’s Niger trip, who the ambassador was, or a classified  report Wilson wrote about his findings prior to the ambassador’s July 6, 2003 op-ed in the New York Times.


We now know, courtesy of the 22-page Libby indictment, that Cheney wasn’t being truthful. Cheney did see the report; he knew full well who Wilson was. He also knew that the CIA arranged for Wilson to travel to Niger, and he personally sought out information about Wilson’s trip to Niger, was briefed about the fact-finding mission, and even obtained classified information about Plame’s covert CIA status. He also came to know one other important nugget: that Plame may have recommended her husband for the trip.


Cheney’s public campaign and that of other White House officials to discredit Wilson and strategically lie about the Plame leak started on Sept. 14, 2003, during an interview with Tim Russert of NBC's Meet the Press.


During the interview, Cheney maintained that he didn’t know Wilson or anything about his trip.


“I don’t know Joe Wilson,” Cheney said, in response to Russert who quoted Wilson as saying there was no truth to the Niger uranium claims. “I’ve never met Joe Wilson. And Joe Wilson -- I don’t know who sent Joe Wilson. He never submitted a report that I ever saw when he came back... I don’t know Mr. Wilson. I probably shouldn’t judge him. I have no idea who hired him and it never came...”


“The CIA did,” Russert said, interjecting.


“Who at the CIA? I don’t know,” Cheney said. “He never submitted a report that I ever saw when he came back.”


What happened once Cheney received information on Plame and Wilson in June 2003 remains unclear. But the indictment illustrates -- in no uncertain terms -- that the vice president’s office staged a concerted effort to undermine Wilson for questioning the veracity of the Niger claims.


Fitzgerald has eyed Cheney in seeking to ascertain who ordered the leak, as previously reported. While the Vice President stands accused of no wrongdoing, his role may come into greater focus during a trial.


In an interview with the syndicated radio program Democracy Now!, Wilson argued that Cheney may have been lying to Russert when he said he didn’t know about the ambassador’s Niger trip.


“While we've never met, he certainly knows who I am and should know unless his memory is flawed and faulty,” Wilson said during the Sept. 16, 2003 interview. “There were at a minimum three reports that had been generated shortly after the Vice President had asked the question, ‘what do we know about this?’”


The vice president certainly must have known Wilson during his tenure as secretary of defense during the first President Bush’s administration. In the weeks leading up to the first Gulf War, Wilson served as the acting US ambassador on the ground in Baghdad. In fact, Wilson was the only line of communication between Washington and Saddam Hussein. The White House held daily briefings with Wilson, and Cheney sat in on a majority of those briefings.


White House Suggested Investigation Was Waste of Time


In hindsight, it now seems that the White House, including President Bush, attempted to steer reporters away from covering the Plame leak by saying the “leaker” would never be found.


On October 7, 2003, Bush and his spokesman, Scott McClellan, said that the White House ruled out three administration officials -- Rove, Libby and Elliot Abrams, a senior official on the National Security Council, as sources of the leak -- a day before FBI questioned the three of them, based on questions McClellan said he asked the men.


The very next day, however, Rove was questioned by FBI investigators and said that he spoke to journalists about Plame for the first time after Novak’s column was published -- a lie, it appears -- based on Time reporter Matthew Cooper’s e-mails which stated that Rove told Cooper about Plame.

Bush told reporters the same day he doubted that a Justice Department investigation would ever turn up the source of the leak, suggesting that it was a waste of time for lawmakers to question the administration and for reporters to follow up on the story.


“I mean this is a town full of people who like to leak information,” Bush said. “And I don't know if we're going to find out the senior administration official. Now, this is a large administration, and there's lots of senior officials. I don't have any idea.”


Senator Frank Lautenberg (D-NJ) responded to the president’s statement in the New York Times: “If the president says, ‘I don't know if we're going to find this person,’ what kind of a statement is that for the president of the United States to make?” “Would he say that about a bank robbery investigation?”


Facing a deadline on turning over documents, e-mails and phone logs to Justice Department officials, Bush said that the White House could invoke executive privilege and withhold some “sensitive” documents related to the leak case. Democrats speculated that the White House had something to hide.


Classified Leak or Truthful Rebuttal?


Unable to keep e-mails from investigators, the White House mounted a defense. They would seek to distinguish between “unauthorized leaks” and something perfectly legal: “setting the record straight.”


On Oct. 6, 2003, in response to questions about whether Rove was Novak’s source, McClellan tried to explain the difference between unauthorized disclosure of classified information and “setting the record straight” about Wilson’s public criticism of the Administration’s handling of intelligence on Iraq.


“There is a difference between setting the record straight and doing something to punish someone for speaking out,” McClellan said.


“There were some statements made (by Wilson) and those statements were not based on facts,” McClellan said. “And we pointed out that it was not the vice president's office that sent Mr. Wilson to Niger.”

Wilson, it turned out, had never said that the vice president’s office had sent him to Niger.

Jason Leopold is the author of the explosive memoir, News Junkie, to be released in the spring of 2006 by Process/Feral House Books. Visit Leopold's website at for updates. John Byrne and Larisa Alexandrovna of Raw Story contributed to this story.

Recent Related Articles

* The Niger Uranium Forgery of December 2003 by Gary Leupp
* Leg Irons for Dickie, Karl and Scooter by Mike Whitney
* Successfully Throwing Sand in the Eyes of the Umpire by Kevin Zeese
* Rove and Cheney Are Now Caught in Fitzgerald's Web by Jason Leopold
* Outing Valerie Plame Put Us All in Greater Danger by Mike Whitney
* Did Rove Rat on Scooter? by Joshua Frank
* After the Libby Indictment, the Press Is Acquitting Itself by Norman Solomon
* At the White House, the Spin Doctor Is Ill by Norman Solomon
* Fitzgerald Expanded Scope of Inquiry in 04 to Probe Niger Forgeries by Jason Leopold

* The Agnew Factor: Clearing the Impeachment Path by Jack Random
* Prosecutor Secures Indictment in CIA Outing Case, Lawyers Say by Jason Leopold
* Après Rove le Déluge by Mike Whitney
* SS Katrina Sinks Bush by Leilla Matsui and Stella La Chance
* Can You Super-Size a Sulzberger? by Ahmed Amr
* Escorting Judy to the Gallows by Mike Whitney
* Miller Had Unusual Relationship with Military, Iraqi Group by Jason Leopold
* Judith Miller’s Bloody Stain on the Press by Ahmed Amr
* Miller’s Confession: The Last Gasp Before the Indictments by Mike Whitney
* Judith Miller, the Fourth Estate and the Warfare State by Norman Solomon
* Some Notes on Current Reporting on Judith Miller by Sam Husseini
* The Public’s Right to Know All About Judith Miller by Ahmed Amr
* Connected at the Roots? Judith Miller, “Scooter” Libby, and the June Notes by Gary Leupp

Other Articles by Jason Leopold

* Rove and Cheney Are Now Caught in Fitzgerald's Web
* Fitzgerald Expanded Scope of Inquiry in 2004 to Probe Niger Forgeries
* Prosecutor Secures Indictment in CIA Outing Case, Lawyers Say

* Miller Entangled in Leak Case Had Unusual Relationship with Military, Iraqi Group
* Bill Frist, The Former 2008 Presidential Candidate
* The GOP’s Fiscal Policies Turned a Natural Disaster Into a Man-Made Catastrophe
* Funeral Co. Charged w Desecrating Corpses Hired to Collect Deceased Hurricane Victims
* Global Warming and Widespread Blackouts are Just as Deadly as Terrorism
* Halliburton Secretly Doing Business with Key Member of Iran's Nuclear Team
* Rove May Have Lied to Feds in Oct. 2003 Testimony, Report Says
* Former Army Sec, Enron VP, Tom White Wants Govt. Funding For New Energy Project
* When is Someone Going to Toss Rumsfeld Into a Cage?
* Watergate Proves That Even Presidents Will Break Laws to Achieve Goals
* BP Faces Huge Fines Related to Unreported Oil Spills in Alaska -- Is ANWR Next?
* Opening ANWR to Development Could Lead to “Exxon Valdez” Type of Disaster
* Bush’s Choice for Energy Secretary Was One of Texas’ Top Five Worst Polluters
* Sinclair Broadcasting's Long History of Journalistic and Corporate Deception

* Under Cheney, Halliburton Helped Saddam Siphon Billions from UN Oil-for-Food Prog.
* Remember When Presidential Campaigns Used to Be About The Issues?
* How Cheney Got Away with $35 Million Before Govt. Launched Probe into Halliburton
* Don't Believe the Hype: Terrorist Warnings Just Another Way Bush Will Steal Election
* Cheney Lobbied Congress to Ease Sanctions Against Terrorist Nations as Halliburton CEO
* Enron’s Lay, Skilling, Washington Lobbyist Knew About Company’s Trading Schemes in CA
* Some of Schwarzenegger’s Energy Advisers Pushing for Dereg. Contributed to Campaign
* Schwarzenegger Pulls a Cheney
* Got Juice? California May Be Saddled With Severe Power Shortages This Summer
* Rice Never Spoke About Al-Qaeda, Osama bin Laden Before 9/11, Investigation Shows
* Company With Ties to VP Cheney's Energy Task Force Faces Criminal Indictment
* VP Cheney Helped Cover Up Pakistani Nuke Proliferation
* Spying On UN Sec. General Part Of Larger Campaign to Undermine UN Missions In Iraq
* Halliburton, VP Cheney’s Former Company Faces Second Criminal Probe In Four Years
* CIA Intel Reports Seven Months Before 9/11 Said Iraq Posed No Threat to US
* O’Neill’s Claims Against Bush Supported By 1998 Letters to By Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz
* Bush Should Face "Long, Hard Slog" of a Campaign, But Dems Busy Fighting Each Other
* Halliburton Doing Biz In Iran, Despite NYC Pension Funds Concerns of Terrorism
* Emails Show Enron May Have Influenced FERC Probe On California Power Crisis, Refunds

* Schwarzenegger’s First Role As Governor-Elect of California: The Deregulator
* Dems Scrap Plans To Look Into Claims White House Manipulated Intel On Iraqi Threat
* The Business of E-Voting and How it Can Put the Wrong Candidate in Office
* Ahnuld, Ken Lay, George Bush, Dick Cheney and Gray Davis
* Wolfowitz: Iraq Was Not Involved In 9-11 Terrorist Attacks, No Ties To Al-Qaeda

* White House Said In Jan. It Used Info From Iraqi Exiles In Bush’s State of Union Speech

* CIA Probe Finds Secret Pentagon Group Manipulated Intelligence on Iraqi Threat

* Tenet Tells Senators Wolfowitz Committee Gave White House Dubious Intelligence

* Wolfowitz Committee Told White House to Hype Dubious Uranium Claims

* “The Road to Hell is Paved With Good Intentions

* CIA Warned White House Last Oct. Iraq/Uranium Claims Based On Forged Docs

* Wolfowitz Aimed to Undermine Blix So US Could Strike Iraq

* White House Silenced Experts Who Questioned Iraq Intel Info Six Months Before War

* Powell Denies Intelligence Failure

* The Iraq War Was Always Based On Shaky Evidence and Bad Intel

* Wolfowitz Admits Iraq War Was Planned Two Days After 9/11

* Despite Thin Intelligence Reports, US Plans To Overthrow Iranian Regime

* Cheney’s Old Company Continues To Break Laws While Profiting From Terror

* FERC and Wall Street: Conversations May Have Violated Federal Law