The Iraq War and MoveOn
by Norman Solomon
www.dissidentvoice.org
August 19, 2005



 

The day after Wednesday night’s nationwide vigils, the big headline at the top of the MoveOn.org home page said: “Support Cindy Sheehan.” But MoveOn does not support Cindy Sheehan’s call for swift withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq.

Many groups were important to the success of the Aug. 17 vigils, but the online powerhouse MoveOn was the largest and most prominent. After a long stretch of virtual absence from Iraq war issues, the organization deserves credit for getting re-involved in recent months. But the disconnects between MoveOn and much of the grassroots antiwar movement are disturbing.

Part of the problem is MoveOn’s routine fuzziness about the war -- and the way that the group is inclined to water down the messages of antiwar activism, much of which is not connected to the organization.

Consider how the MoveOn website summarized the vigils: “Last night, tens of thousands of supporters gathered at 1,625 vigils to acknowledge the sacrifices made by Cindy Sheehan, her son Casey and the more than 1,800 brave American men and women who have given their lives in Iraq -- and their moms and families.” Such a gloss excludes a key reason why many people participated in the vigils: They wanted to express clear opposition to any further U.S. involvement in the war.

Despite its high-profile role in the vigils this week, MoveOn is still not giving a high priority to addressing the Iraq war in its ongoing work. When I went to the MoveOn website today and looked at its roster of “Current Campaigns,” just a single item on the list was focused on Iraq -- and that one, from June, involved “demanding that Bush address the evidence in the ‘Downing Street Memo.’”

The political action wing of MoveOn has committed itself to supporting congressional legislation, co-sponsored by Reps. Walter Jones and Neil Abercrombie, which would require the president to start withdrawing troops from Iraq ... by October 2006.

In contrast, MoveOn never supported Rep. Lynn Woolsey’s resolution, introduced early this year, stating that, “the president should develop and implement a plan to begin the immediate withdrawal of United States Armed Forces from Iraq.” Nor has MoveOn gotten behind Rep. Barbara Lee’s more recent bill to prevent the establishment of permanent U.S. military bases in Iraq.

What if MoveOn were to directly ask its 3 million members (people who’ve signed up for its e-mailings) whether they favor the idea of waiting till autumn 2006 before the start of U.S. troop withdrawal from Iraq -- or whether, on the other hand, those members would prefer that withdrawal get underway before the end of this year? I believe that most MoveOn members would opt for the latter scenario. But MoveOn policy is set by a few individuals who have not been willing to put such options in front of members for a vote.

On Tuesday, the day before the vigils, Cindy Sheehan said in a conference call that the Jones-Abercrombie timeline is “not soon enough.” She doesn’t see any good reason to continue the U.S. military occupation; she’s opposed to any delay in pulling out. And while it’s all well and good for MoveOn to tell people to “Support Cindy Sheehan,” the MoveOn leadership should publicly explain why the organization refuses to join her in supporting a swift withdrawal of all U.S. troops from Iraq.

During the next few weeks, MoveOn will have an opportunity to devote some of its appreciable resources to strengthening the antiwar movement. With an umbrella theme of “End the War on Iraq -- Bring the Troops Home Now,” protests in Washington and elsewhere are on the calendar for Sept. 24-26. The national coalition United for Peace & Justice is playing a key role in creating momentum for those demonstrations, which will begin an autumn of historic antiwar activism. Hopefully, MoveOn will catch up with its grassroots base and get involved in a supportive way.

Norman Solomon is the author of the new book War Made Easy: How Presidents and Pundits Keep Spinning Us to Death, from which this article is excerpted. For more information, visit: www.WarMadeEasy.com. He can be reached at: mediabeat@igc.org.

* Read an Interview with Norman Solomon about War Made Easy by Adrian Zupp

Related Articles

* Bush Launches “Operation Cindy Sheehan” by Ahmed Amr
* Blaming the Antiwar Messengers by Norman Solomon
* Mona in the Field of Crosses at Camp Casey, TX by Greg Moses
* Cindy Sheehan Confronts Judith Miller’s War by Ahmed Amr
* SING GOD DAMN IT by Patricia Goldsmith
* Get a Life, Mr. President by Peter Kurth
* Rage Against the Killing of the Light by Norman Solomon
* The Revolution is NOW... by Sheila Samples
* Plaming Cindy Sheehan by Ahmed Amr
* C'mon Dubya, Talk to the Lady by Ken Sanders
* How Building a Saudi City Made a Lefty Out of Dick Underhill, VFP by Greg Moses
* Plame Games Expose WMD “Intelligence Failure” Scam by Ahmed Amr
* Fire Sulzberger and Judith Miller for WMD Hoax by Ahmed Amr
* Is Sulzberger Hiding Judith Miller in Jail? by Ahmed Amr
* Plame Games Originated with Judith Miller by Ahmed Amr
* Judith Miller is No Martyr and Sulzberger is No Saint by Ahmed Am

Other Recent Articles by Norman Solomon

* Blaming the Antiwar Messengers
* Rage Against the Killing of the Light
* Media Flagstones Along a Path to War on Iran
* The Incredible Blight of TV Punditry
* In Praise of Kevin Benderman
* “Wagging the Puppy” -- and Unleashing the Deadly Dogs of War
* Thomas Friedman, Liberal Sadist?
* General Westmoreland's Death Wish and the War in Iraq
* Sidney Blumenthal vs. Norman Solomon on Karl Rove, the Democrats and Iraq
* Judith Miller -- Drum Major for War
* Mourn on the 4th of July
* Voluntary Amnesia in the Service of War
* Picture-Perfect Killers
* Letter From Tehran: In Washington's Cross-Hairs
* From Watergate to Downing Street -- Lying for War
* War Made Easy: From Vietnam to Iraq
* The Silent Media Curse of Memorial Day
* And Now, It's Time For... “Media Jeopardy!”
* News Media and "the Madness of Militarism"
* Nuclear Fundamentalism and the Iran Story
* Iraq: War, Aid and Public Relations
* The New Pope and Journalism’s Crisis of Faith
* When Media Dogs Don’t Bark
* A Quarterly Report from Bush-Cheney Media Enterprises
* Little Reporting of Paranoia in High Places
* Why Iraq Withdrawal Makes Sense
* MoveOn.org: Making Peace With the War in Iraq
* Ex-Presidents as Pitchmen: Touting Good Deeds
* Great Media Critics: Intrepid for Journalism and Labor Rights
* What They Really Mean...
* Iraq Media Coverage: Too Much Stenography, Not Enough Curiosity
* Of Death Be Not Proud
* A Shaky Media Taboo -- Withdrawal from Iraq
* Far From Media Spotlights, the Shadows of “Losers”
* Acts of God, Acts of Media
* Media Sense and Sensibilities
* Tailgated by Media Technology
* The Limits of “Man Bites Dog” Stories
* Announcing the P.U.-litzer Prizes for 2004

HOME