HOME
DV NEWS
SERVICE ARCHIVE LETTERS SUBMISSIONS/CONTACT ABOUT DV
Hoopa
Tribe, Federal Government Reject
Westlands
Trinity Proposal
by
Dan Bacher
Dissident
Voice
October 25, 2003
Citing
the lack of any “new science,” the Hoopa Valley Tribe on October 17 rejected a
proposal by the Westlands Water District to settle their lawsuit blocking
Trinity River restoration.
“We
listened to their proposal in good faith and had our scientists analyze it, but
we found no new science that justifies setting aside of the 20 years of science
created to support the Trinity Record of Decision,” said Joe Jarnaghan, Hoopa
Tribal Councilman.
Westlands
presented the proposal to representatives of the Hoopa Valley and Yurok tribes
and the federal government during a meeting earlier that week in Sacramento.
The
water district, joined by the Northern California Power Association and
Sacramento Utility District, filed the lawsuit after Bruce Babbitt issued the
historic Record of Decision in December 2000. The ROD would increase Trinity
flows to restore salmon and steelhead populations, giving 47 percent of Trinity
flows to fish and the remaining 53 percent to agricultural and hydroelectric
users.
The
tribe turned down the proposal after a team of scientists from the tribe’s
trustees, the Bureau of Reclamation (BOR) and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service (USFWS), told the tribe they would give the Westlands settlement
proposal no further consideration.
“We
are very pleased that our trustees evaluated this proposal so quickly,” said
Mike Orcutt, Director of the Hoopa Valley Tribal Fisheries Department. “We did
not want this proposal to become a repeat of the 18 months that were wasted on
analyzing the proposal from SMUD. The U.S. Geological Survey eventually
declared that plan unworkable, but every analysis of an alternative to the ROD
creates the potential for another fish kill.”
In
a letter sent to the two federal agencies, the tribe said, “the Westlands
proposal has no credible biological or scientific justification to support it.”
SMUD
and one member of the NCPA, the City of Palo Alto, pulled out of the litigation
this spring, due to pressure from the tribes, anglers and environmental groups,
but the other partners remain in the litigation.
“We’re
disappointed about the rejection of the settlement by the tribe and the federal
government,” said Tupper Hull, spokesman for the Westlands Water District. “We
thought our proposal was a very reasonable settlement. It very much mirrors the
restoration strategies in the ROD.”
The
ROD was based on the premise that flows must mimic natural flows to push young
steelhead and salmon downstream, replenish spawning gravel and clear out
vegetation. Hull said their proposal would provide 92 percent of the ROD’s
flows - and yet not impact Central Valley growers as dramatically as the ROD
would.
“The
difference between 92 percent and 100 percent is not measurable,” noted Hull.
“It would achieve exactly the same benefits as the ROD and is a considerably
reasonable and viable proposal. We are confident and hopeful that the parties
will continue to look at the proposal - and it is incumbent on others to bring
their recommendations to the table.”
The
Westlands Water District comprises 540,000 acres of land on the west side of
the San Joaquin Valley. About 100,000 acres are fallow - and the district is
planning to retire up to 200,000 acres, since it hasn’t been been able for 12
years to receive 100 percent of its allocation of 1.15 million acre feet of
water. “The water district has only been able to rely on half of its allocation
in an average delivery year,”said Hull.
However,
tribes and environmental groups dismissed the proposal as a “public relations
stunt.” “This is an attempt by Westlands to convince people that they are doing
the right thing when they’re not,” said Craig Tucker, outreach director of
Friends of the River. “It’s not an offer made in good faith.”
Fishery
conservation groups and the tribes have for many years criticized the
allocation of subsidized federal water to Westlands, since the water is used to
irrigate soil that should have never been farmed because of the high
concentration of selenium and other toxic minerals in the soil. Besides the harm to fish that occurs because
of the diversion of water from the Trinity and other watersheds, the intensive
farming has resulted in the discharge of toxic minerals and pesticides into the
San Joaquin River, the Delta and San Francisco Bay.
Mike
Orcutt noted that the Westlands proposal contained “too many unresolved
hypotheses” to be a valid plan for the protection of the Trinity River fishery.
“Westlands
consultants freely admitted they only had a few weeks to put their document
together. Westlands doesn’t seem to realize that the ROD is a product of
careful science and long negotiations about the minimum flows needed to keep
the river healthy for fish,” said Orcutt.
The
Trinity is the largest tributary of the Klamath River - and produces 30 to 50
percent of the total number of the salmon in the Klamath watershed, depending
upon the year. A Bush administration shift in water policy in the Klamath Basin
to benefit farmers at the expense of fish resulted in the deaths of over 34,000
fish in the lower Klamath in September 2002. Karl Rove, White House political
strategist, engineered the policy shift to curry favor among agribusiness for
an Oregon Republican senator facing re-election.
A
large percentage of the fish killed were destined for the Trinity.
Unfortunately, the Westlands lawsuit blocked the release of flows that could
have alleviated the fish kill.
The
Hoopa Valley Tribe plans to pursue Congressional legislation to implement the
ROD. “This protracted litigation has brought the river’s fish population to
dangerously low levels,” said Jarnaghan. “We are asking Congress to keep its
word about leaving us enough water for a healthy river. We have no choice but
to fight. We don’t have another river to live next to. The fish don’t have
another river to spawn in.”
Daniel
Bacher is an outdoor writer/alternative journalist/satirical
songwriter from Sacramento California. He is also a long-time peace, social
justice and environmental activist. Email: danielbacher@hotmail.com
* Federal
Government Intervenes in Butte Creek Salmon Disaster
* Thousands
of Klamath Fish Die After Power Company Shuts Off Water
* Sacramento
Becomes First Inland City In California To Adopt A Living Wage Ordinance
* Department
of Interior Launches Investigation Into Klamath Basin Decisions
* Bush
Administration Releases Trinity Water in Wake of Iron Gate Scandal
* Hoopa
Tribe, Commercial Fishermen Alarmed Over Closed Door Water Accord
* Pastors
for Peace Caravan Challenges Cuba Blockade for Fourteenth Time
* Yurok
Tribe Denounces Water 2025 Conference As A Big Sham
* Butterflies and
Farmworkers Versus the USDA and Riot Cops