HOME
DV NEWS
SERVICE ARCHIVE SUBMISSIONS/CONTACT ABOUT DV
by
Mickey Z.
June
16, 2003
"It is not true that life is one damn thing after another -
it's one damn
thing over and over."
-- Edna St. Vincent Millay
So,
there may not be WMD after all...why is anyone surprised? Whenever the U.S. has
needed a pretext for military intervention, it has fabricated or provoked it.
Zachary Taylor's excursions in Mexican territory, the sinking of the Maine, the
porous 38th Parallel, the safety of medical students in Grenada, April
Glaspie's engraved invitation to Saddam Hussein, Noreiga's drug dealing, and
famine in Somalia...to name but a few.
As
George W. Bush declared on March 17, 2003, the night he gave Saddam Hussein a
final ultimatum, "The United States and other nations did nothing to
deserve or invite this threat, but we will do everything to defeat it."
It's
an excuse we all learn in childhood: "He started it" or "She hit
me first." From this rudimentary alibi grows the myth of the sleeping
giant. By portraying oneself as the target of an unprovoked or impending sneak
attack, all bases are covered. Not only are you claiming innocence and the role
of a victim, you might even be excused for responding angrily...maybe even with
a little too much force.
If
we are to trust our history books and newspaper headlines, we'd almost certainly
come to this conclusion: The United States benevolently minds its own business
but is incessantly awakened by surprise events and unprovoked incidents that
test its celebrated patience...incidents like the aforementioned sinking of the
Maine or the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor-after which Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto,
Commander of the Japanese Fleet, is reported to have said: "I fear we have
awoken a sleeping giant."
Interestingly,
Yamamoto's quote is yet another example of spin. There is no official record of
the Japanese commander uttering those words...except for the 1970 feature film,
"Tora! Tora! Tora!" Thank you, Hollywood.
It
may actually be Napoleon Bonaparte who deserves credit for this term. Legend
has it he pointed to China on a map of the world and growled: "There is a
sleeping giant. Let him sleep! If he wakes, he will shake the world."
Regardless
of who said it first, as with all myths, the "U.S. as Sleeping Giant"
façade crumbles rapidly under scrutiny. Here are two examples.
The
Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941 is the mother of all
sleeping giant spins. The day after the attack, Franklin Delano Roosevelt
addressed Congress. The U.S. was "at peace" with Japan, he stated, yet
had been "suddenly and deliberately attacked." Yet, as historian
Thomas A. Bailey wrote: "Franklin Roosevelt repeatedly deceived the
American people during the period before Pearl Harbor... He was like the
physician who must tell the patient lies for the patient's own good."
The
diplomatic record reveals some of what Dr. Roosevelt neglected to tell
his
easily deluded patients in that now-mythical "Date of Infamy" speech:
*
Dec. 14, 1940: Joseph Grew, U.S. Ambassador to Japan, sends a letter to
FDR,
announcing that, "It seems to me increasingly clear that we are bound
to
have a showdown [with Japan] some day."
*
Dec. 30, 1940: Pearl Harbor is considered so likely a target of Japanese
attack
that Rear Admiral Claude C. Bloch, commander of the Fourteenth Naval
District,
authors a memorandum entitled, "Situation Concerning the Security
of
the Fleet and the Present Ability of the Local Defense Forces to Meet
Surprise
Attacks."
*
Jan. 27, 1941: Grew (in Tokyo) sends a dispatch to the State Department:
"My
Peruvian Colleague told a member of my staff that the Japanese military
forces
planned, in the event of trouble with the United States, to attempt a
surprise
mass attack on Pearl Harbor using all of their military
facilities."
*
Feb. 5, 1941: Bloch's December 30, 1940 memorandum leads to much discussion and
eventually a letter from Rear Admiral Richmond Kelly Turner to Secretary of War
Henry Stimson in which Turner warns, "The security of the U.S. Pacific
Fleet while in Pearl Harbor, and of the Pearl Harbor Naval Base
itself,
has been under renewed study by the Navy Department and forces afloat for the
past several weeks... If war eventuates with Japan, it is believed easily
possible that hostilities would be initiated by a surprise attack upon the
Fleet or the Naval Base at Pearl Harbor... In my opinion, the inherent
possibilities of a major disaster to the fleet or naval base warrant taking
every step, as rapidly as can be done, that will increase the joint readiness
of the Army and Navy to withstand a raid of the character mentioned
above."
*
Feb. 18, 1941: Commander in Chief, Admiral Husband E. Kimmel says, "I feel
that a surprise attack on Pearl Harbor is a possibility."
*
Sept. 11, 1941: Kimmel says, "A strong Pacific Fleet is unquestionably a
deterrent
to Japan-a weaker one may be an invitation."
*
Nov. 25, 1941: Secretary of War Henry L. Stimson writes in his diary that, "The
President...brought up entirely the relations with the Japanese. He brought up
the event that we're likely to be attacked [as soon as] next Monday for the
Japanese are notorious for making an attack without warning."
*
Nov. 27, 1941: U.S. Army Chief of Staff George C. Marshall issues a memorandum
cautioning that "Japanese future action unpredictable but hostile action
possible at any moment. If hostilities cannot...be avoided, the United States
desires that Japan commit the first overt action."
*
Nov 29, 1941: Secretary of State Cordell Hull, responding to a speech by Japanese
General Hideki Tojo one week before the attack, phones FDR at Warm Springs,
GA to warn of "the imminent danger
of a Japanese attack, and urge him to return to Washington sooner than planned.
In
light of this record, why were the Americans caught with their pants down on
December 7? Never underestimate the collective power of arrogance and racism.
"Many
Americans, including Roosevelt, dismissed the Japanese as combat pilots because
they were all presumed to be 'near-sighted'," writes Kenneth C. Davis.
"There was also a sense that any attack on Pearl Harbor would be easily
repulsed." (It's not hard to imagine a similar intelligence conclusion
being reached pre-9/11.)
When
things didn't turn out as imagined and the U.S. Navy was devastated at Pearl
Harbor, the sleeping giant spin put it right.
"Through
the darkness, from the West and South, the intruders boldly sped. There were at
least six of them, Russian-designed Swatow gunboats armed with 37-mm and 28-mm
guns, and P-4's. At 9.52 they opened fire on the destroyers with automatic
weapons, and this time from as close as 2,000 yards. The night glowed eerily
with the nightmarish glare of air dropped flares and boat's searchlights. Two
of the enemy boats went down."
No,
this isn't Tom Clancy; it's Time Magazine in August 1964. "While on routine
patrol in international waters, the U.S. destroyer Maddox underwent an
unprovoked attack," declared Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara.
The
Washington Post headline on Aug. 5, 1964 read: AMERICAN PLANES HIT NORTH VIETNAM
AFTER SECOND ATTACK ON OUR DESTROYERS; MOVE TAKEN TO HALT NEW AGGRESSION.
"The official story was that North Vietnamese torpedo boats launched an
'unprovoked attack' against a U.S. destroyer on 'routine patrol' in the Tonkin
Gulf on Aug. 2-and that North Vietnamese PT boats followed up with a
'deliberate attack' on a pair of U.S. ships two days later," write Jeff
Cohen and Norman Solomon.
President
Lyndon Johnson, speaking on national television on the evening of August 4,
1964, announced air strikes against North Vietnam. In response, the Los Angeles
Times exhorted readers to "face the fact that the Communists, by their
attack on American vessels in international waters, have themselves escalated
the hostilities."
"Shortly
after the events in the Gulf of Tonkin, Lyndon Johnson met with congressional
leaders and lobbied them to grant him broad powers to respond to the supposed
provocation," says historian Donald R. Shaffer. "House and Senate
leaders quickly acceded to his request."
By
a nearly unanimous vote by Congress passed the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution on
August 7, 1964, thus authorizing Johnson "to take all necessary measures to
repel any armed attack against the forces of the United States and to prevent
further aggression." Over the next two years, 400,000 U.S. soldiers shipped
out to South Vietnam.
Propaganda
patterns often border on predictability. Like the U.S.S. Maine, the Maddox was
not on a pleasure cruise. "U.S. ships had been supporting South Vietnamese
commando raids into North Vietnam," says Shaffer. The crew of the Maddox
was gathering intelligence to support those raids. Despite the aggressive
nature of its mission, there is still no reason to believe the Maddox was fired
upon.
According
to Cohen and Solomon, "Cables from the U.S. task force commander in the
Tonkin Gulf, Captain John J. Herrick, referred to 'freak weather effects,'
'almost total darkness' and an 'overeager sonarman' who 'was hearing ship's own
propeller beat.'"
Squadron
commander James Stockdale, who would later serve as Ross Perot's running mate
in 1992, was a navy pilot flying over the Gulf of Tonkin that night. "I
had the best seat in the house to watch that event," Stockdale recalled,
"and our destroyers were just shooting at phantom targets-there were no PT
boats there.... There was nothing there but black water and American fire
power."
"There
was no battle. There was not a single intruder, never mind six of them,"
Ben Bradlee of the Washington Post states bluntly. "Never mind Russian
designed Swatow gunboats armed with 37mm and 28mm guns. They never opened fire.
They never sank. They never fired torpedoes. They never were."
One
year after the dubious incident, Lyndon Johnson admitted: "For all I know,
our Navy was shooting at whales out there."
Or
maybe it was Saddam?
Mickey Z. is the author
of The Murdering of My Years: Artists and Activists Making Ends Meet (www.murderingofmyyears.com) and
an editor at Wide Angle (www.wideangleny.com).
He can be reached at: mzx2@earthlink.net.