HOME
DV NEWS
SERVICE ARCHIVE SUBMISSIONS/CONTACT ABOUT DV
Cows
and Armed Guards on a College Campus
Where
is the Truth Amid All This Subterfuge?
by
Robert Fisk
in
Baghdad
April
2, 2003
It
was a most peculiar day. Overnight, the Americans had pulverised a
neo-Classical office block next to what was before a previous pulverisation
the Iraqi government's Department of Air Armaments.
Then,
just before 10am yesterday, an aircraft could be heard diving high over Baghdad
and a clap of sound from the other side of the Tigris, with the usual
grey-black column of smoke, signalled the end of another annexe belonging to
the sons of Saddam. Then came the bus trip.
The
Iraqis wanted to take the press to see another example of US and British
"imperialist-racist violence" and so we were trucked off to the
outskirts of the city, to the campus of what was described as a ladies
education college. Campus it was, with agricultural blocks and plant testing
fields and a perimeter of palm groves. And the crime against humanity to which
we were taken? A large crater in the lawn beside a women's dormitory, a hundred
smashed windows and some broken power lines. A hundred metres away, I found
four black and white cows tethered in the grass and, perhaps 30 feet from the
crater, a slit trench with sand-bags; surely, we told ourselves, an ordinary
part of any college campus.
Now
let's be fair. College staff have every right to take their own protection
against America's notoriously inaccurate "smart" bombs. But did they dig
the slit trench? Did they park the civilian trucks and buses, scattered around
the empty campus, 30 metres from each other and always under the foliage of
trees? And if college personnel normally worked the gates, why was the campus
guarded by armed and green-uniformed militiamen? The crater was 20ft deep the
classic cruise missile's gouge in the ground and its blast was enormous.
Internal doors were torn from their hinges, desks overturned, beds thrown
across rooms. But no one was hurt; indeed, the college had been abandoned long
before the attacks.
Now
fast-forward to a press conference a couple of hours later by the ubiquitous,
bespectacled and uniformed minister of information, Mohamed Saeed al-Sahaf, who
announced casualties in Baghdad for the previous 36 hours of air raids as 125
wounded and 24 dead.
His
figures for other governorates were, of course, somewhat less: 18 wounded in
Qadasiyeh and three dead, in Babylon more than 100 wounded and 18 dead,
including nine children in the Hilla district (from which, by chance, Mr Sahaf
himself comes). But this provoked an obvious question.
Why
did the bus not take us to the hospitals to talk to the 125 wounded rather than
the empty women's college with its broken windows and four uncommunicative
cows? Of course, bureaucracy here works in Ottoman fashion, no more so than in
this former capital of the Caliphs. Someone in authority had the bright idea of
allowing Arab cameramen for Reuters and the Associated Press to travel to
Babylon to take video footage of the aftermath of a battle that the Iraqis
claim to have fought successfully. And that was that.
Mr
Sahaf's most dramatic moment, however, came at the start of his daily press
conference when he said American aircraft had attacked two buses on the highway
between Baghdad and Amman carrying western "human shields", including
Europeans and Americans. "The brave Americans have started shooting at the
Americans and Europeans of different nationalities," he announced not,
I thought, without some satisfaction at further evidence of American "barbarism".
But then again, we know as a fact that the Americans attacked a Syrian bus last
week just after it had crossed the frontier into Iraq, reportedly killing five
passengers. And the British soldier whose own unit was attacked by US
"friendly fire" last week he also condemned the air assault for
endangering Iraqi civilians described the American pilot as a
"cowboy". Anything, in other words, could be true.
It's
getting hotter in Baghdad in every sense of the word and in one month the
temperature will rise to 35C. The dense black shroud of oil smoke that covers
the city is now creating a sinister fog peace activists have not yet
complained of the damage this may do to the health of Iraqi children which
makes even the mildest of air raids into things of mystery. At 4.45pm yesterday
came the sound of jets yet again, followed by a series of short, sharp
explosions that lasted for up to a minute. They sounded all too familiar to my
ears, the rumble of cluster bombs legal against armour but decidedly illegal
if used against civilians. I stared for 10 minutes through the smoke from a
high-rise apartment block, to no avail. Whether the bombs were dropped in the
suburbs, on a military barracks or in a built-up area was not possible to
discover.
Nor
is the status of Baghdad in this war. Far from being besieged, its main roads
north and south are open a few trains are still leaving for northern cities
and although US troops were reported to have set up a checkpoint on the road
west to Amman, they appear to have been a "flying column", stopping
trucks and cars for a few hours and then vanishing into the desert at night.
By
evening, Vice-President Ramadan was back he has the intriguing habit of never
looking at anyone who asks him a question to insist that 6,000 Arab
volunteers have arrived in Iraq to fight the Americans and British, half of
them anxious for "martyrdom".
Mr
Ramadan repeated yet again Iraq had no weapons of mass destruction and spent
some time claiming the Americans and British might plant such weapons in Iraq
to fool the world and justify their invasion. The Saudi Foreign Minister,
Prince Saud al-Faisal, was Mr Ramadan's and thus Saddam's target. "He
has offered advice which is something he is in the habit of doing and his
advice is he would like to see our leader leave his post," Mr Ramadan
thundered. "Let me tell this lackey, this stooge, this small entity they
know full well who his cousin is, the so-called Prince [Ambassador] Bandar in
Washington, and who he works for. Let them [the Saudis] say to him: 'Go to
hell. All we wish for is that you do not have an Arab name...' Let me tell you,
you are too small, too much of a nothing, to say a word to the leader of Iraq.
Those who give up will be swept away from the land of the Arabs." Which
did little for Iraqi-Saudi relations.
Robert Fisk is an award winning foreign
correspondent for The Independent
(UK), where this article first appeared. He is the author of Pity Thy
Nation: The Abduction of Lebanon (The Nation Books, 2002 edition). Posted
with authors permission.