Palestinian genetic studies indicate that they are related to other indigenous people of the region. ‘Exotic’ genetic input is relatively small, but includes both sub-Saharan African, other Middle Eastern, and European (Eastern Mediterranean and Balkan). In this regard, Palestinians are a typical Middle Eastern people – Ashkenazis less so.

Mizrahim are more closely related to Palestinians than they are to Ashkenazim – but as Middle Eastern genetics are dispersed over a wide area it is not certain that the Mizrahim can trace ancestry to Canaan, but instead to the region in general, perhaps from ancient Berbers. Many Jews, whether Ashkenazim or not – are the descendents of converts and may trace no ancestry to the region.

The salient point, whatever the genetic findings, is that Palestinians were the people who inhabited Palestine when the Brit/Zionist concerted colonization effort began less than a century ago. It is for this reason that Palestinians are entitled to inhabit and re-inhabit Palestine. As far as Jews going back – there is no where to go back to – most have now been born in Palestine. This does not stop, of course, Jews who want to leave from doing so.

Judaism is the religion, Jews are an ethnicity or ethnicities. The Ashkenazim of Europe were an ethnic group apart from their neighbors. Whether differences between say, Romanian Jews and Lithuanian Jews, were sufficient to regard them as different ethnicities is hard to say. However, suffice it to say that Sephardic Jews are of different ethnicity to Ashkenazis – and Mizrahi Jews, Yemenis, Cochin Jews and others may all be viewed as different ethnicities. In Israel, the imposed national effort is to create one ethnicity- the Israeli Jew. This has not been entirely successful.

But Judaism as a religion means subscribing to a set of particular beliefs in their various forms. Many Jews in Israel are secular – they do not practice Judaism, and may be observant of custom only as cultural practice. So Jewish ethnicity and Judaism are two different – if related – entities. There may have been a time when the religion and the ethnicity were one and the same. It would have been a brief period if at all. Jews have been mixing with other groups through both intermarriage and conversion since antiquity.

Jewish ethnicity may be viewed as similar to Arab ethnicity in that it includes people of all backgrounds. The simple requirement of being considered an Arab (self-identified or identified from without) is that one speak Arabic as first language. This holds true whether one’s ancestry is Berber, Nilotic, Phoenician or Sumerian – or Arabian Peninsula Arab. Similarly, Jews have ancestries from a number of groups – a few of which overlap those of Arabs.

Zionism is a legitimate term. It represents a movement begun among assimilated Ashkenazis in 19th century Western Europe to create a homeland for unassimilated Jews for whom it was feared would never be accepted into Gentile European society. This movement grew amidst the political milieu of the era – one that was nationalist (and increasingly ultra-nationalist), colonialist, and imperialist. It is not surprising that Zionism did not acknowledge their ideology might be examined from the viewpoint of its victims. In the view of Zionists, the Arabs of Palestine were not a People in a European sense – that of being a nation. Zionists viewed Jews as a misplaced nation – a People without a state. And they would remedy that predicament via colonization made possible by a powerful sponsor – as it turned out, a very willing Britain.

I would very much like to see the demise of the ‘State of the Jews’ and its replacement by the ‘State of all its citizens.’ I expect however, that a less than ideal 2-state solution is in the offing.

so, as land robbers/imperialists, they differ only to a degree from british, italian, chinese, french, german, russian, indian, pakistani, iraqi, turkish, serb, belgian, dutch, spanish, portugese, austrian, hungarian, et al supremacism/robbery.

one shld always remember that what happened to ashk’c voelken [in english, folks] cld have happened to any of us.

if i had been as child armed with eternal verities such that my people are chosen by god; leaders/mentors of lesser-valued folk, etcetc.
i too might have behaved just like ohlmert, dayan, peres, meir, begin, et al.
but, again who knows? tnx

If those GOYIM Europeans Jews(Ashke-NAZI or SPANISH Sephardim) are “SEMITIC HEBREWS”,then “ARAB” like me MUST be German,since I or(we Arabs)genetically DO NOT SHARE any DNA heritage with those GOYIM EUROPEAN JEWS.We are genetically proven NOT to be related.

•Most if (NOT all) Europeans Jews today have NO links to ancient Hebrews let alone the Israelites(Arab Palestinians’ Forefathers).

•As for Mizrahim.Most of Mizrahi Jews(with exception to Arab Jews)are genetically LINK to NON-Semitic Middle Eastern people like Iranians, Kurds, and Turks(NOTHING WRONG WITH THEM)But NOT RELATED or NO LINK with Semitic Arabs.

•And most if Not all of North Africans Jews are either Barber or SPANISH Sephardim descends
•Judaism or Jewishness is a Religion and a way of life,NOT ETHNICITY OR RACE. The ethnic Race of People were the ISRAELITES(genetically blood descendants/seeds of man named Jacob/Israel), and JACOB/ISRAEL is the blood father of today palestinians)

•The Irony is Most Jews Do NOT even SHARE the same DNA between themselves, rather they share it with the Local people whom they Lived with, a STRONG Indication which Confirm again that Judaism is a Religion NOT Race

•Two options are available for those goyim reptilian jews shape shifters:-

1.EITHER Goyim Jews must live with us the Native indigenous ARAB Palestinians[Genetically proven to be blood descendants of Ancient Hebrews],and share the home-land with us in JUSTICE, EQUALITY and PEACE ……[i.e ACCEPT THE ONE STATE SOLOUTION THAT IS TO BE SHARED BY ALL OF US].

2.OR leave our own home land PALESTINE and go to HELL, and never attempt to come back again

Apartheid ethno-cratic Israel that has been built on foundation of Zionism , a racist ideology and value that is similar to that of NAZI Germany and Apartheid South Africa ..MUST BE PUT TO END..OKAY?

So to all Mankind say all together:-

الموت لإسرائيل

Death to Israel

Mort à Israël

Muerte a Israel

以色列去死

Смерть Израилю

Morte a Israel

イスラエルに死

Morte a Israele

इज़राइल की मौत

מוות לישראל

Tod Israel

Dood aan Israël

•As for Mizrahim.Most of Mizrahi Jews(with exception to Arab Jews)are genetically LINK to NON-Semitic Middle Eastern people like Iranians, Kurds, and Turks(NOTHING WRONG WITH THEM)But NOT RELATED or NO LINK with Semitic Arabs.

•And most if Not all of North Africans Jews are either Barber or SPANISH Sephardim descends
•Judaism or Jewishness is a Religion and a way of life,NOT ETHNICITY OR RACE. The ethnic Race of People were the ISRAELITES(genetically blood descendants/seeds of man named Jacob/Israel), and JACOB/ISRAEL is the blood father of today palestinians)

•The Irony is Most Jews Do NOT even SHARE the same DNA between themselves, rather they share it with the Local people whom they Lived with, a STRONG Indication which Confirm again that Judaism is a Religion NOT Race

•Two options are available for those goyim reptilian jews shape shifters:-

1.EITHER Goyim Jews must live with us the Native indigenous ARAB Palestinians[Genetically proven to be blood descendants of Ancient Hebrews],and share the home-land with us in JUSTICE, EQUALITY and PEACE ……[i.e ACCEPT THE ONE STATE SOLOUTION THAT IS TO BE SHARED BY ALL OF US].

2.OR leave our own home land PALESTINE and go to HELL, and never attempt to come back again

Apartheid ethno-cratic Israel that has been built on foundation of Zionism , a racist ideology and value that is similar to that of NAZI Germany and Apartheid South Africa ..MUST BE PUT TO END..OKAY?

So to all Mankind say all together:-

الموت لإسرائيل

Death to Israel

Mort à Israël

Muerte a Israel

以色列去死

Смерть Израилю

Morte a Israel

イスラエルに死

Morte a Israele

इज़राइल की मौत

מוות לישראל

Tod Israel

Dood aan Israël

The only solution to solve the problem is the middle east is to stop supporting the racist Zionist. Of course Israel will keep bombing Palestine. Of course they will blame it on Hamas.. “By way of deception”.

The problem is the Racist Zionists. It’s that simple.

Rabbi speaking the truth about Israel:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T1GNY61J59E

Today, most Jews in Israel are secular. They pay attention to religious practices largely as cultural artifacts, not because of any deep held belief. Non-Jews are punished for not being of the dominant race/ethnicity, not because they have a different religion. In fact, the Israeli state cares not a with whether an Arab is religiously observant or not. It’s the fact of not being a Jew that matters.

But you are right that Muslims, Christians and Jews did get along better in the old days – more or less, with that pendulums swinging a bit over time. But then again, those Jews were not Zionists – they did not come to replace the natives.

I don’t think a one-state solution is viable. There is far too much hatred on the part of Israeli Jews, and anger on the part of Palestinians. After all, we see how Israel treats its Palestinian citizen population – it wants to evict them! Maybe 200 years down the road, kum-ba-ya may come into focus but for now I’d like to see a Palestinian state in all of what remains of Palestine.

With regard to “wisdom” and “shining light upon our darkness,” those quotes don’t come from me.

According to official Roman Catholicism, if you confess your sins – and mean it, you will go to heaven.

Mary – There appears to be some evolution going on among either Palestinians or cockroaches. By the time of the second quote, Eitan has Palestinians crawling on all fours, a definite improvement over a cockroaches ‘all eights.’ Now if he can just get the Palestinians walking up-right.

“WHEN WE HAVE settled the land, all the Arabs will be able to do about it will be to scurry around like drugged cockroaches in a bottle.”—Rafael Eitan, April 14, 1983

“We declare openly that the Arabs have no right to settle on even one centimeter of Eretz Israel…Force is all they do or ever will understand. We shall use the ultimate force until the Palestinians come crawling to us on all fours.”—Rafael Eitan, April 13, 1983

http://www.washington-report.org/archives/Jan_Feb_2005/0501021.html

But you seem mistaken about the concept of religious marriage in Israel. Are you Jewish and want to get married? Go to a Jewish religious court. Muslim? Hello Mosque! Christian? Where’s that padre? Don’t confuse the civil marriage (marriage licenses are all recognized, even some whacky ones for fringe religions) with the religious marriage however.

Just remember, according to Catholics you’re going to burn in hell anyway, not matter what you do or don’t. Ain’t religion fun?!

Yes, freedom of religion, but only to practice it. Don’t think about political power unless you are Jewish – in which case you don’t even have to practice it.

And by the way – there is no freedom from religion. One has to marry through the religious courts. That’s how they keep Jews from out-marrying.

And you know I’m right about Israel stealing water from Palestinian aquifer. And I’m right about the genetics.

Ashkenazi have disregarded Sask in favour of Manitoba… From there the
Aspers control most of Canada’s media.

In response to the Balfour Declaration of 1917, Lord Montague (“Jewish”) wrote the following:

I lay down with emphasis four principles:

1. I assert that there is not a Jewish nation. The members of my
family, for instance, who have been in this country for
generations, have no sort or kind of community of view or of
desire with any Jewish family in any other country beyond the fact
that they profess to a greater or less degree the same religion.
It is no more true to say that a Jewish Englishman and a Jewish
Moor are of the same nation than it is to say that a Christian
Englishman and a Christian Frenchman are of the same nation: of
the same race, perhaps, traced back through the centuries -
through centuries of the history of a peculiarly adaptable race.
The Prime Minister and M. Briand are, I suppose, related through
the ages, one as a Welshman and the other as a Breton, but they
certainly do not belong to the same nation.

2. When the Jews are told that Palestine is their national home,
every country will immediately desire to get rid of its Jewish
citizens, and you will find a population in Palestine driving out
its present inhabitants, taking all the best in the country, drawn
from all quarters of the globe, speaking every language on the
face of the earth, and incapable of communicating with one another
except by means of an interpreter. I have always understood that
this was the consequence of the building of the Tower of Babel, if
ever it was built, and I certainly do not dissent from the view,
commonly held, as I have always understood, by the Jews before
Zionism was invented, that to bring the Jews back to form a nation
in the country from which they were dispersed would require Divine
leadership. I have never heard it suggested, even by their most
fervent admirers, that either Mr. Balfour or Lord Rothschild would
prove to be the Messiah.

I claim that the lives that British Jews have led, that the aims
that they have had before them, that the part that they have
played in our public life and our public institutions, have
entitled them to be regarded, not as British Jews, but as Jewish
Britons. I would willingly disfranchise every Zionist. I would be
almost tempted to proscribe the Zionist organisation as illegal
and against the national interest. But I would ask of a British
Government sufficient tolerance to refuse a conclusion which makes
aliens and foreigners by implication, if not at once by law, of
all their Jewish fellow-citizens.

3. I deny that Palestine is to-day associated with the Jews or
properly to be regarded as a fit place for them to live in. The
Ten Commandments were delivered to the Jews on Sinai. It is quite
true that Palestine plays a large part in Jewish history, but so
it does in modern Mahommendan history, and, after the time of the
Jews, surely it plays a larger part than any other country in
Christian history. The Temple may have been in Palestine, but so
was the Sermon on the Mount and the Crucifixion. I would not deny
to Jews in Palestine equal rights to colonisation with those who
profess other religions, but a religious test of citizenship seems
to me to be the only admitted by those who take a bigoted and
narrow view of one particular epoch of the history of Palestine,
and claim for the Jews a position to which they are not entitled.

If my memory serves me right, there are three times as many Jews
in the world as could possible get into Palestine if you drove out
all the population that remains there now. So that only one-third
will get back at the most, and what will happen to the remainder?

4. I can easily understand the editors of the Morning Post and of the
New Witness being Zionists, and I am not in the least surprised
that the non-Jews of England may welcome this policy. I have
always recognised the unpopularity, much greater than some people
think, of my community. We have obtained a far greater share of
this country’s goods and opportunities than we are numerically
entitled to. We reach on the whole maturity earlier, and therefore
with people of our own age we compete unfairly. Many of us have
been exclusive in our friendships and intolerant in our attitude,
and I can easily understand that many a non-Jew in England wants
to get rid of us. But just as there is no community of thought and
mode of life among Christian Englishmen, so there is not among
Jewish Englishmen. More and more we are educated in public schools
and at the Universities, and take our part in the politics, in the
Army, in the Civil Service, of our country. And I am glad to think
that the prejudices against inter-marriage are breaking down. But
when the Jew has a national home, surely it follows that the
impetus to deprive us of the rights of British citizenship must be
enormously increased. Palestine will become the world’s Ghetto.
Why should the Russian give the Jew equal rights? His national
home is Palestine. Why does Lord Rothschild attach so much
importance to the difference between British and foreign Jews? All
Jews will be foreign Jews, inhabitants of the great country of
Palestine.

I do not know how the fortunate third will be chosen, but the Jew
will have the choice, whatever country he belongs to, whatever
country he loves, whatever country he regards himself as an
integral part of, between going to live with people who are
foreigners to him, but to whom his Christian fellow-countrymen
have told him he shall belong, and of remaining as an unwelcome
guest in the country that he thought he belonged to.

and in such a tiny, impoverished land? i do not wish such a fate for no people. come to saskatchevan. canadian govt’s love you. test them. ask for all, much, or half of beautiful saskatchevan where you wldn’t be surrounded by eternal enemies.

and if amers, canadians love you so much, why don’t they establish a homeland for pals in saskatchevan or kansas? and then you cld live in peace in yishrael?
what do you think a canadian gov’t wld say to that?
thnx

but ashk’m have much disdain for all shemites and about 90% of them do not live in israel.
some of which may tire of israel and its lamentations. no people can for ever keep on killing, torturing, imprisoning, land stealing, etc., and receive accolades for it.

even a mere look reveals that ashk’m are nonshemitic; i.e., descendants of shem.
more and more ashk’m speak out against israelis crimes and push for one state solution.
so, mebosa is correct, jews will remain in canaan after first comming to it some 3,200 yrs ago.
perhaps only 1o% of the ashk’c peoples are now for onestate solution.
it’s a wave now but in decades to come it may become a tsunami .thnx

CRAP YOU HAVE WRITTEN

ISRAEL HAS NO RIGHT TO EXIST. ONE STATE FOR ALL
Jewish state of Israel has no right to exist.
Perhaps the Israelis should bottle the drool dripping